1.1 Treatment Considerations
A first step in treatment decisions regarding otitis media must focus on accurate diagnosis to distinguish the normal examination from that of acute otitis media (AOM) from otitis media with effusion (OME) or a retracted tympanic membrane (TM) without middle ear effusion. Acute bacterial sinusitis is defined by an inflammation of the mucosa of the paranasal sinuses caused by bacterial overgrowth in a closed cavity; the disorder is also called acute bacterial rhinosinusitis (ABRS). Persistent AOM and ABRS are defined as the persistence of symptoms and signs during or shortly (<1 month) following antibiotic therapy. Recurrent AOM and ABRS are defined as three or more separate episodes in a 6-month time span or four or more episodes in a 12-month time span. Chronic OM and sinusitis occur when there is a persistence of symptoms and signs for 3 months or longer ().
Antibiotic treatment of AOM and ABRS hastens recovery and reduces complications, but uncomplicated AOM and ABRS usually have a favorable natural history regardless of antibiotic therapy. Patients with persistent or recurrent AOM or ABRS more frequently have infections caused by antibiotic-resistant bacterial pathogens; a combination of host, pathogen, and environmental factors results in a markedly reduced spontaneous cure rate (approximately 50% in most studies). In the absence of appropriate treatment, chronic otitis media and chronic ABRS infrequently resolve without significant sequelae.
GABHS (Group A beta-hemolytic streptococci) infection produces a self-limited, localized inflammation of the tonsillopharynx generally lasting 36 days. Antibiotic treatment, if prompt and appropriate, reduces the duration of symptoms, shortens the period of contagion, and reduces the occurrence of localized spread and suppurative complications. A major objective of administering antibiotics is to prevent rheumatic fever ().
1.2 Additional Considerations in Antibiotic Selection
A number of factors can be implicated when initial empiric antibiotic treatment fails: (1) inadequate dosing, (2) poor absorption of orally administered antibiotics, (3) poor patient compliance, (4) poor tissue penetration, or (5) the presence of copathogens. Before prescribing an antibiotic, the clinician must consider several factors: (1) bacterial resistance patterns within the patients community, (2) the severity and duration of the infection, (3) any recent antibiotic therapies, (4) patient age, (5) past drug response, (6) any risk factors that may preclude an agent from the decision-making process, (7) product cost, and (8) availability. Before prescribing an antibiotic, the clinician should also consider the likely susceptibility of the suspected pathogen, as well as the patients allergy history.
Analgesics, decongestants, antihistamines, nasal sprays, and anti-inflammatory agents have been used to relieve symptoms, to treat, and to attempt to prevent the development of infections. None is particularly helpful. Systemic or local treatments (for example, topical analgesic ear drops for AOM) may reduce the pain associated with the infection, but this is perhaps only at the early stages of pathogenesis.
As noted in the guidelines, consideration should be given to comparative compliance features and duration of therapy in antibiotic selection in children. The main determinants of compliance are frequency of dosing, palatability of the agent, and duration of therapy. Less frequent doses (once or twice a day) are preferable to more frequent doses that interfere with daily routines. In many instances, palatability of the drug ultimately determines compliance in children.
Patients (and parents) prefer a shorter course of antibiotic therapy (5 days or less) rather than the traditional 10-day courses often used in the United States. Many patients and parents continue antibiotic therapy only while symptoms are present, perhaps followed by an additional 1 or 2 days; the remainder of the prescription may be saved for future use when similar symptoms arise. A 10-day treatment course with antibiotic has been standard in the United States although 3-, 5-, 7-, and 8-day regimens are frequently used in other countries. There is microbiologic and clinical evidence that shorter treatment regimens are effective in the majority of AOM and ABRS episodes.
Antibiotic cost is an interesting component of the treatment paradigm. Drug costs alone rarely reflect the total cost of treating an illness. For example, three office visits and three injections of intramuscular ceftriaxone would greatly escalate the cost of treatment. However, the cost of loss of work or school attendance as a result of treatment failure and repeat office visits for additional evaluation are also important yet often overlooked factors.
1.3 Antibiotic Treatment for AOM and ABRS
Factors favoring development of persistent and recurrent AOM and probably ABRS include: (1) an episode of infection in the first six months of life, (2) patient age less than 3 years, (3) parental smoking, and (4) day care attendance ().
Today, antibiotic choices should reflect pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic data and clinical trial results demonstrating effectiveness in eradication of the most likely pathogens based on tympanocentesis (and sinus) sampling and antibiotic-sensitivity testing. Thereafter, compliance factors (e.g., formulation, dosing schedule) and accessibility factors (e.g., availability, cost) should be taken into account. Studies from the early 1990s have described significant decreases in the susceptibility of upper respiratory bacteria to various antibiotics. After the introduction of a 7-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine in 2001 in the US, the prevalence in middle ear aspirates of H. influenzae increased and S. pneumoniae decreased.