To Marcella Markham and Harold Lang for whom energy was eternal delight.
Introduction
This book is an introduction to directing narrative screen drama. It aims to serve the potential feature film director, the independent filmmaker, the director of television series, as well as students making their college (or school) projects. Although an introduction, some practicing directors may also find it an interesting, and occasionally provocative, discussion of their craft.
What distinguishes this book from other texts on the market is that it integrates both actor-direction (working with actors) and technical-direction (working with camera, audio, and the crew). Almost a century has passed since the principals of modern acting were codified, and still some professional directors have only the sketchiest idea of how to direct actors. For these directors, a movie or a television program is primarily a technical exercise. I believe that if screen drama is to progress beyond its current obsession with mundane reality, if it is to refresh and reinvent itself, it has to empower actors and place the fundamental director- actor relationship at the heart of the process.
I have spent many years in British television, film, and theater, working as a stage manager, an assistant director, and a director. I have also spent years studying the system in the United States. This book describes the successful practices I encountered in both counties, and reflects an approach to film and television programmaking that is primarily industry-oriented. I am not concerned in this book with the fascinating issues that surround experimental work or any work other than narrative drama. Budding Kenneth Angers, Harry Smiths, and Stan Brakhages will find little consolation here. However, the book does try to accommodate the work and concerns of such filmmakers as John Cassavetes, Jean-Luc Godard (in his narrative mode), and Mike Leigh, all of whom are especially preoccupied with performance and how it is captured.
This book also reflects my many years of working with students, trying to discover the best approach to teaching directing. It broadly reflects my classroom approach, which addresses performance issues first and technical matters second. As with students, I encourage readers of this book to learn what the industry considers good practice before evolving their own styles. I offer some very specific suggestions about the way certain things should be done (such as marking the shooting script). Having considered my approach, readers are encouraged to develop their own. A tension between contemporary industry practice and innovation will always exist. I cannot teach innovation, but I can suggest a methodology that may be used as a foundation for creative individuals to build upon, adapt, or thoughtfully reject. One has to learn a discipline in order to unlearn it.
I present topics in this book in the order followed by any film or television projectpreproduction, production, and postproduction. Although I have found that a few students adhere to the big-bang theory of production, whereby a production magically explodes into existence in an act of improvisation on the day of the shoot, nothing could be further from the reality of filmmaking. Even directors known for improvisation, such as Cassavetes and Leigh, spend many weeks refining their scripts and working with their actors before commencing production. I have tried to present preproduction as the most creative stage, full of the research, discovery, and exciting decision-making that will define production and postproduction.
The following pages include examples from my own experience (often presented as sidebars). I hope that these will give readers who may not have worked on a professional project a taste of the realities of production.
Finally, I have tried to define technical terms when they first appear, but please note that they are also collected in the Glossary at the end of the book.
Acknowledgments
I am grateful to a number of individuals and institutions for helping me with this book.
I would like to thank Emerson College for a faculty development grant that enabled me to interview a large number of working professionals in Los Angeles. I am also grateful to the American Academy of Television Arts and Sciences for allowing me to participate in its annual academic seminar. Among the many helpful ATAS members, Id particularly like to mention Price Hicks for her commitment to the seminar, and Bruce Bilson for sharing a portion of his vast experience of directing in Hollywood with me.
Id like to thank Silman-James Press for so readily embracing the notion of this book, and Jim Fox for his patience, meticulous editing, and creative suggestions. A number of colleagues have graciously contributed to this manuscript in one way or another, including Robert Todd, Jane Shattuc, and Eric Schaeffer. For several years I have taught a class on directing in conjunction with a class on acting for the camera, and I would like to salute my co-teacher Ken Cheeseman for his inexhaustible energy and commitment to the subject.
I am indebted to Carole Flynt for allowing me unfettered access to the staff and crew of E.R. I am also very grateful indeed to the producers of NYPD Blue , General Hospital , and The Young and the Restless for spending precious time with me and allowing me to observe their productions and interview crew members.
I would like to thank the gifted directors whose comments are included in the last chapter of the book for sparing me time in their busy schedules. And Id like to thank Kevin Bright for explaining the U.S. system of sitcom production to me.
Thanks too to Lauren Byrne, Avani Batra, Aaron Seliquini, and Larry Laska for their help. I am also grateful to the numerous industry professionals and Emerson students from whom Ive learned so much. And finally, I would like to express my appreciation to my illustrator, John Lanza, for his talent, patience, and humor.
Part 1: Preproduction
1. Director and Script
Were the cinema to disappear I would simply accept the inevitable and turn to television; were television to disappear, I would revert to pencil and paper. For there is a clear continuity between all forms of expression. Its all one. Jean-Luc Godard
Directing is the sum-total of artistic and technical operations which enables the play as conceived by the author to pass from the abstract, latent state, that of the written script, to concrete and actual life on the stage. Jacques Copeau, Encyclopedie Franaise, December 1935.
M ost of this book is about what a screen director does, but Id like to start by considering what a screen director is . A director is a storyteller who usually works with a script and all the available visual and audio resources to bring a story to life in the most vivid and compelling way. Directors are like orchestra or opera conductors in that they work with performers to realize a work. In so doing, they develop a particular approach to or interpretation of a script, be it a classic such as Shakespeare or an entirely new creation. This is the theatrical element of a screen directors job achieving a good, interesting, and unique realizationand half of this book is concerned with describing it. However, a screen director controls the recording and editing of a performance too and, although these processes have strong elements of artistry, they also pose technical challenges. The all- important recording and editing of a performance in the most expressive and efficient way is what the other half of this book describes.