Carlton Smith - Cold-Blooded: A True Story of Love, Lies, Greed, and Murder

Cold-Blooded

A True Story of Love, Lies, Greed, and Murder

Carlton Smith

When a woman of bad character marries she earns the admiration of her set, she has worked the trick and become respectable, but he, the man, only earns its ridicule he is the mug Believe me, to conduct yourself gracefully in such a position you need either great dignity of character or an unparalleled effrontery

W. Somerset Maugham

Ashenden

September 2001

City of Industry, California

Larry

Laren

Shantar

Blanche

Elisa and Sarah

Scheffel

Shane

The Truth

The sun was still below the eastern horizon as Gregory Whalen left his hotel room on his way to the barns and the horses. He always fed at 5, and the horses knew it, so they would be waiting for him. The early morning air was cool, but it would soon warm up.

Ahead in the early morning darkness, on a strip of grass walking her dog, Whalen saw his clientone of them, at least. Elisa McNabney was a beautiful womantall, dark, slender, with a vivacity that was inescapably seductive, at least to men. Elisa could look at you with her merry dark eyes and pin you with your own thoughts, even if you were, like Whalen, 72 years of age and old enough to know better.

Elisa looked up as Whalen approached.

Youll never guess what happened, she said.

What?

Larrys gone, Elisa said.

Gone? Where the hell did he go?

He left last night, Elisa said. We had an argument. He left. Hes said hes going back to the cult.

Nonplussed by this disclosure, Whalen said nothing. Elisas dog, Morgan, a Jack Russell terrier, sniffed at the grass. So Larry wont be showing anymore? Whalen finally asked, coming to grips with the practical implications of this surprise. That was Greg: forget the philosophy, focus on the immediate.

No, Elisa said. He said hes done with showing.

Whalen nodded. He turned and headed toward the barns, thinking the whole thing was strange, but then, rich people tended to be strangeat least, that was Whalens experience with them. After all the work that had been done, all the money that had been spent, to just throw it all away on a whimto go join a cult? It wasnt like Larryor was it? As he entered the hotel elevator, Whalen thought back over the past few days, and when he replayed them in his mind, he realized that something had been brewing, all right.

They had arrived at the horse show in the City of Industry, about forty minutes east of Los Angeles, on the Wednesday before, September 5. Whalen had brought the horses down from northern California in his trailer, accompanied by his daughter, Deborah Kail, like her father, a trainer, as well as an insurance broker who specialized in casualty coverage on expensive show horses, like those of the McNabneys. Larry and Elisa had followed them down in Larrys shiny new red Ford pickup truck, the one with the dark-tinted windows and dual rear wheelsa dually, it was calledthat had cost Larry close to $50,000 earlier in the summer. Theyd all checked into the Pacific Palms hotel and prepared for the Pacific Quarter Horse Classic, the first of two four-day shows where trainers and owners of American quarter horses, like Greg and Debbie, and Larry and Elisa, put their prized animals on display. Just like a big dog show, as Debbie Kail described it later, although it had as much in common with a fashion show as anything else. As the McNabneys trainers, it was Whalen and his daughters job to get the McNabney horses ready for the exhibitions. That meant exercising them, washing them, grooming them, all to make them look pretty as well as muscular. It was a full-time job, at least for Greg Whalen.

Whatever one said about Larry and Elisa, the McNabney horses, at least, were champions. One, Justa Lotta Page, Larrys yearling stallion, was worth at least $30,000 and maybe, quite soon, even a lot more. Tall, handsome, well-muscled, the sorrel-colored colt had a promising future in the American quarter horse sweepstakes. If things went right, Justa Lotta Page could eventually be sold to a breeder for many times what he had originally costjust $12,500when Larry McNabney had bought him as an 8-month-old colt from Whalen at the first of the year.

Quarter horses were Greg Whalens businesshad been for more than forty years, ever since hed quit riding rodeo bulls in his native Texas, and started making money from horse fanciers instead. It was a long way from the days when Whalens father had raised broncos for the U.S. Army, back before World War II. From his ranch near Clements, California, north of Stockton, Whalen was something of a cross between a coach, a confessor, a barber and a chauffeur. His stock in trade was his knowledge of the American quarter horse breed. Greg bred the mares, picked the foals, raised them, trained them, then groomed them, mostly while acting as the agent of a steady stream of paying customers who formed the backbone of the horse show circuitpeople, for the most part with a superabundance of both time and money, and an animating interest in displaying both. Exhibiting an American quarter horse wasnt for either the faint of heart or the weak of pocket, as more than one trainer like Whalen had pointed out to a would-be client. In a sense, participating in horse shows was a bit like owning a large yacht: if you had to ask how much it cost, you couldnt afford it. A serious exhibitor, like Larry was turning out to be, could easily spend $100,000 in one year on obtaining a horse, training, board and care, veterinary fees, transportation, accommodations and entry fees, and if the horse was a dogso to speakthe money could never be recouped.

Whalen had known the McNabneys for about three years. Larry, he knew, was a big-time lawyer from Nevada who had made a pile in personal injury lawsuits, mostly in Reno. Elisa, almost twenty years younger than Larry, was his fifth wife. She was the one who handled all the money. As Elisa had explained it to Gregs daughter, Debbie, Larry didnt like to be bothered with financial details, that was her job. Larrys income, when it came, came in great gushing gobs, Elisa had explained; it was the nature of the business of representing clients in personal injury casesfeast or famine, as Elisa put it. Money would grow tight for a bit, then wham!in came a huge settlement for some lawsuit, and the coffers would be filled to overflowing again. It all depended how fast Larry could make the insurance companies settle up, and for how much.

Still, it didnt seem to Greg that Larry was practicing much law these days. Ever since Greg had sold Larry Justa Lotta Page, on January 1, 2001, Larry had spent most of his timeand a lot of moneyshowing the horse. So far, Whalen and the McNabneys had been pretty much all over the West with the prized animal: Scottsdale, Arizona; Las Vegas, Nevada; Central Point, Oregon; Monroe, Washington; Fallon, Nevada; and a number of venues in California where prize horses were similarly exhibited.

Justa Lotta Page hadnt been broken to the saddle yet. Instead, he had been entered in halter competition, common for yearlings. This was where Larry, or Greg himself, simply led the colt into the center of the ring by means of a head halter. Points were awarded by the judge or judges based on the way the horse lookedits conformance, that is, its shape and muscle tone, along with its ability to respond to the directions of the human holding the rope. So, too, was the halter handler judgedon his own looks and demeanor as he directed the horse through a series of paces.