BLOOD WORK
A Tale of Medicine and Murder in the Scientific Revolution
HOLLY TUCKER
W. W. NORTON & COMPANY
New York London
Copyright 2011 by Holly Tucker
All rights reserved
For information about permission to reproduce selections from this book, write to Permissions, W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 500 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10110
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Tucker, Holly.
Blood work: a tale of medicine and murder in the scientific revolution / Holly Tucker.1st ed.
p.; cm.
Includes bibliographical references.
ISBN: 978-0-393-07055-2
1. BloodTransfusionEuropeHistory17th century. 2. Denis, Jean Baptiste, d. 1704. I. Title. [DNLM: 1. Denis, Jean Baptiste, d. 1704. 2. Blood TransfusionhistoryEurope. 3. History, 17th CenturyEurope. 4. HomicidehistoryEurope. 5. Human ExperimentationhistoryEurope. 6. Public OpinionEurope. 7. SciencehistoryEurope. WB 356]
RM171.T787 2011
615.39dc22
2010046340
W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.
500 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10110
www.wwnorton.com
W. W. Norton & Company Ltd.
Castle House, 75/76 Wells Street, London W1T 3QT
For Audrey, heart and soul, moon and stars,
always and forever
Very many maintain that all we know is still infinitely less than all that still remains unknown.
William Harvey, De motu cordis (1628)
Blood is a juice of a very special kind.
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Faust, Part 1 (1808)
Contents
Note on Translations
In all circumstances, I have first relied on period translations of the original foreign-language texts cited. In the absence of a period translation, the remaining translations are my own. The source of the quote (printed translation or translated original) is indicated in the notes that accompany the text. Minor changes have been made to regularize spelling or typography, but these do not impact the original meaning.
Dramatis Personae
France | England |
Louis de Basril (dates unknown) outspoken lawyer in the Paris parliament | Robert Boyle (162791) chemist; founding fellow of the Royal Society, corresponded with Richard Lower |
Jean-Baptiste Colbert (161983) prime minister to Louis XIV | Charles II (163085) king of England; restored to the throne in 1661 after the execution of his father and the subsequent rule of Oliver Cromwell |
Jean-Baptiste Denis (c. 16351704) physician and transfusionist | Timothy Clarke (died 1672) physician; founding fellow of the Royal Society, performed human infusion experiments with Christopher Wren |
Ren Descartes (15961650) philosopher; espoused the theory of mind-body dualism and the idea that the body was a machine | Thomas Coxe (c. 16401730) fellow of the Royal Society; replicated Lowers canine transfusions at the Royal Society with Edmund King |
Paul Emmerez (died 1670) surgeon; Denis assistant | Arthur Coga (dates unknown) first transfusion patient in England |
Nicolas Fouquet (161580) Louis XIVs superintendent of finances; former political heir apparent to Prime Minister Mazarin | William Harvey (15781657) physician; announced discovery of blood circulation in 1628 |
Pierre Gassendi (15921655) philosopher; Descartes intellectual rival, member of the Montmor Academy | Robert Hooke (16351703) architect, microscopist; founding fellow of the Royal Society; former assistant to Thomas Willis, performed air-pump experiments on animals with Robert Boyle |
Christian Huygens (162995) astronomer, mathematician; former member of the Montmor Academy, founding member of Louis XIVs Academy of Sciences | Edmund King (16291709) replicated Lowers canine transfusions at the Royal Society with Thomas Coxe |
Guillaume Lamy (164483) physician; member of the Paris Faculty of Medicine; outspoken critic of transfusion | Richard Lower (163191) physician; fellow of the Royal Society, performed first transfusion experiments in England |
Louis XIV (16381715) king of France, also called the Sun King; began personal reign in 1661, following the death of Prime Minister Jules Mazarin | Henry Oldenburg (161977) German-born diplomat and natural philosopher; secretary of the Royal Society |
Henri-Martin de la Martinire (163476) physician; once a doctor on corsair (pirate) ships; outspoken critic of transfusion | John Wilkins (161472) founding member and first secretary of the Royal Society, with Henry Oldenburg |
Antoine Mauroy (died 1668) Denis famous patient; died following a transfusion in April 1668 | Thomas Willis (162175) physician and anatomist; fellow of the Royal Society, studied the human brain with the help of Robert Hooke and Christopher Wren |
Perrine Mauroy (dates unknown) wife of Antoine Mauroy | Christopher Wren (16321723) architect, astronomer, mathematician; founding fellow of the Royal Society; performed blood infusion experiments with Thomas Willis |
Henri-Louis Habert de Montmor (c. 160079) nobleman; founder of the Montmor Academy for the Sciences |
Ren Moreau (15871656) physician; member of the Paris Faculty of Medicine |
Claude Perrault (161388) physician, architect; member of the Paris Faculty of Medicine, founding member of Louis XIVs Academy of Science; performed canine transfusions in the kings library |
Nicolas de la Reynie (16251704) first police chief of Paris; appointed by Louis XIV |
Samuel de Sorbire (161570) permanent secretary of the Montmor Academy |
Prologue
O n December 14, 1799, Americas first president awoke with a sore throat, which was soon accompanied by a fever. At six that morning, George Washingtons doctors agreed it was time for a bloodletting. Eighteen ounces of blood later, the patients condition had not improved, and he was bled twice more. Not long after, Washington was unable to breathemedical historians believe that he suffered from an infection of the epiglottisand a tracheotomy was performed. A fourth round of bloodletting followed, to no avail. Washington gasped for breath like a drowning man and died late that evening, around ten oclock.
Though we will never know whether Washington died of his illness or of the severe bloodletting he suffered during his treatment, many historians would bet on the latter. His body was laid out in the familys formal parlor so that prominent visitors could pay their respects. Yet as the nation prepared to mourn its first president, others wondered if there was a way to bring him back to life.
When Washingtons granddaughter, Mrs. Thomas Law, arrived the next morning, she brought with her a man who suggested the unthinkable. Dr. William Thornton, best known as architect of the U.S. Capitol, speculated that the president could be revived if both blood and air were returned to his corpse. Dr. Thornton suggested that Washington be warmed up by degrees and by friction so his blood might be coaxed to move once again through his body. Then Thornton proposed to open a passage to the lungs by the trachea, and to inflate them with air, to produce artificial respiration, and to transfuse blood into him from a lamb.