Yellow Perils
Yellow Perils
China Narratives in the
Contemporary World
E DITED BY
Franck Bill and Sren Urbansky
Copyright
2018 University of Hawaii Press
All rights reserved
Printed in the United States of America
23 22 21 20 19 18 6 5 4 3 2 1
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Bill, Franck, editor. | Urbansky, Sren, editor.
Title: Yellow perils: China narratives in the contemporary world / edited by Franck Bill and Sren Urbansky.
Description: Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, [2018] | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2018004207 | ISBN 9780824875794 (cloth: alk. paper)
Subjects: LCSH: ChinaForeign public opinionCase studies. | ChineseForeign countriesSocial conditionsCase studies. | RacismCase studies. | Model minority stereotypeCase studies.
Classification: LCC DS740.4 .Y447 2018 | DDC 303.48/251dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018004207
Cover art: China loves Africa #37 by Kenyan artist Michael Soi.
University of Hawaii Press books are printed on acid-free paper and meet the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Council on Library Resources.
Acknowledgments
P ART OF THE RESEARCH featured in this book was made possible through an Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) grant, which funded the project Where the Rising Powers Meet (ES/J012335/1) that ran at the University of Cambridge between 2012 and 2015.
The authors also gratefully acknowledge the additional financial support from the German Research Foundations Graduate School for East and Southeast European Studies (LMU Munich/University of Regensburg), which funded and hosted a workshop in Munich in July 2015.
In addition, the institutional support of the LMU Munich, the University of Cambridge, the Mongolia and Inner Asia Studies Unit (Cambridge), and the University of California, Berkeley, was invaluable and provided wonderfully collegial and supportive environments.
Heartfelt thanks go as well to our colleagues, who generously offered comments and suggestions on early drafts of chapters presented at conferences in Cambridge, Chicago, Munich, and Makuhari. Particular thanks go to Amy Matthewson and Flair Donglai Shi, whose own work on the Yellow Peril led to many stimulating conversations.
This book in its final form would not have been possible without the input and guidance of our wonderful editor Pamela Kelley and her editorial associate Debbie Tang. It was a pleasure to work with both of them, and with copy editor Jennifer McIntyre, who made sure our prose always remained legible!
Finally, we would like to thank Michael Soi for the cover image, Jose Santos for the overall cover design, and Anja Dreves for compiling the index.
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
FRANCK BILL
I N NOVEMBER 2011 , after several months of intense discussion, Icelandic interior minister gmundur Jnasson formally rejected a bid by Chinese billionaire Huang Nubo to purchase 115 square miles of wild heathland in the northeast of the country. The bid, intended for the construction of a holiday resort including a golf course and hot-air balloon rides, had attracted much attention both nationally and internationally. While the plot of land was both landlocked and barren, the transfer of a sizable portion of the countryamounting to 0.3 percent of the countrys landmassto a foreign national had generated much anxiety. At a time when Iceland was recovering from a devastating economic crisis, the prospect of selling part of its territory was seen as a desperate and dangerous move. The fact that the bid had been made by a Chinese citizen compounded these fears and raised additional security concerns that the transfer of land might give Beijing a strategic foothold in the North Atlantic (Jackson and Hook 2011).
Huang Nubo, described as a mountaineer and a poet, is said to have fallen in love with Iceland on his first visit in 2010, a passion originally awakened in his youth by a friendship with a kind Icelandic student (Trellevik 2013). As he explained in numerous interviews (Kim Blog 2011), his choice of location for the holiday resort was tied to this long-held fascination for the country. However, in Western news outlets much was also made of Huangs prior involvement with the propaganda department of Chinas Communist Party, especially when, after being turned down by Iceland, he attempted to purchase land near Troms in northern Norway (Eysteinsson 2015) and was rumored to be eyeing large plots of land on Svalbard (Lindbad 2014, Morgunblai 2014). For some commentators, his interest in the Arctic region had less to do with his personal fascination in the region than with Chinas own ambition to claim a stake in the Arctica region that is likely to become an important site of extraction of natural resources as new technologies develop and global temperatures continue to rise.
In their descriptions of Huang Nubo as a puppet of the Chinese state (Higgins 2014), Western media coverage of the story echoed a more general disquiet about Chinas meteoric rise and its ever-expanding economic and cultural footprint. This anxiety is perceptible in the treatment of China-related issues in the news. Along with the vast body of literature that has emerged in the last decade about Chinas rise (see Pan 2012), a sizable share of these academic and popular texts feature the words power and threat in their titles (Frayling 2014: 34). China thus appears to be located at a critical juncture between being an object of admiration and something to be feared.
A recent political video perfectly illustrates this ambivalence. Produced by the Americans for Prosperity Foundation and released during the 2010 midterm elections, and then again during Mitt Romneys presidential campaign (Citizens Against Government Waste 2010), the video depicts a Chinese professor addressing a hall of students in 2030 Beijing:
Why do great nations fail? The Ancient Greeks [], the Roman Empire, the British Empire, and the United States of America. They all make the same mistakes, turning back on the principles that made them great. America tried to tax and spend itself out of a great recession. Enormous so-called stimulus spending, massive changes to health care, government takeover of private industries, and crushing debt. Of course, we owned most of their debt. So now they work for us. (Yeats 2013: 267)
At this point, the whole audience erupts into laughter.
On the one hand, the 2030 China depicted in the video is successful and powerful. The professor is both eloquent and confident, and the students look affluent. Well-dressed and using the latest technology, they would not look out of place at an Ivy League university ( than a university professor, emphasizes this.