Penguin supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part of it in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin to continue to publish books for every reader.
Denise Levertov, In the Japanese tongue... , from Poems 1960-1967. Copyright 1966 by Denise Levertov. Reprinted by permission of New Directions Publishing Corp.
This is dedicated to Neshama Franklin.
I dont know Whoor whatput the question, I dont know when it was put. I dont even remember answering. But at some moment I did answer Yes to Someoneor Somethingand from that hour I was certain that existence is meaningful and that, therefore, my life, in self-surrender, had a goal.
One
BEGINNING
I t can be too sad here. We so often lose our way.
It is easy to sense and embrace meaning when life is on track. When there is a feeling of fullnesshaving love, goodness, family, work, maybe God as parts of lifeits easier to navigate around the sadness that you inevitably stumble across. Life holds beauty, magic and anguish. Sometimes sorrow is unavoidable, even when your kids are little, when the marvels of your children, and your parental amazement, are all the meaning you need to sustain you, or when you have landed the job and salary for which youve always longed, or the mate. And then the phone rings, the mail comes, or you turn on the TV.
Where do we even begin in the presence of evil or catastrophedead or deeply lost children, a young wifes melanoma, polar bears floating out to sea on scraps of ice? What is the point of it all when we experience the vortex of interminable depression or, conversely, when we recognize that time is tearing past us like giddy greyhounds? Its frightening and disorienting that time skates by so fast, and while its not as bad as being embedded in the quicksand of loss, were filled with dread each time we notice life hotfoot it out of town.
One rarely knows where to begin the search for meaning, though by necessity, we can only start where we are.
That would be fine, when where we find ourselves turns out to be bearable. What about when it isntafter 9/11, for instance, or a suicide in the family?
I really dont have a clue.
I do know it somehow has to do with sticking together as we try to make sense of chaos, and that seems a way to begin. We could start with something relatively easy: C. S. Lewis famously said about forgiveness, If we really want to learn how to forgive, perhaps we had better start with something easier than the Gestapo.
Maybe, counterintuitively, it makes sense to start right off with hard, rather than easy: Where is lifes meaning after Katrina, or an unwanted divorce?
If were pressed for an answer, most of us would say that most of the time we find plenty of significance in life as it unfurls in front of us like a carpet runnerat least when it goes as expected, day by day, with our families and a few close friends. We have our jobs and those we work or play or worship or recover with as we try to feel a deeper sense of immediacy or spirit or playfulness. Most people in the world are striving simply to feed their kids and hang on. We try to help where we can, and try to survive our own trials and stresses, illnesses and elections. We work really hard at not being driven crazy by noise and speed and extremely annoying people, whose names we are too polite to mention. We try not to be tripped up by major global sadness, difficulties in our families or the death of old pets.
People like to say that itsignificance, importis all about the family. But lots of people do not have rich networks of hilarious uncles and adorable cousins, who all live nearby, to help them. Many people have truly awful families: insane, abusive, repressive. So we work hard, we enjoy life as we can, we endure. We try to help ourselves and one another. We try to be more present and less petty. Some days go better than others. We look for solace in nature and art and maybe, if we are lucky, the quiet satisfaction of our homes.
Is solace meaning? I dont know. But its pretty close.
The kids say, It is what it is. They can say this with a straight face since they have not had kids yet. I remember my youth, and having that same great confidence in bumper stickers and my own thinking. Say its true: It is what it is. Were social, tribal, musical animals, walking percussion instruments. Most of us do the best we can. We show up. We strive for gratitude, and try not to be such babies.
And then theres a mass shooting, a nuclear plant melts down, just as a niece is born, or as you find love. The world is coming to an end. I hate that. In environmental ways, its true, and in existential ways, it has been since the day each of us was born.
Its pretty easy to think you know the meaning of life when your children are small, if they come with all their parts and you get to live in that amazing cocoon of oneness and baby smells. But what if your perfect child becomes sick, obese, an addict or a homeless adult? What if you wake up at sixty and realize that you forgot to wake up, and you never became the person you were born to be, and now your hair is falling out?
Youre thinking about this for the first time when maybe its a little late. Your life is two-thirds over, or youre still relatively young, but your girl went from being two years old to being eleven in what felt like eighteen months, and then in what felt like eight weeks to fifteen, where she has been now, sharply dressed as a bitter young stripper, for as long as you can fricking remember.
Oh, honey, buckle up. It gets worse.
Where is meaning in the meteoric passage of time, the speed in which our lives are spent? Where is meaning in the pits? In the suffering? I think these questions are worth asking.