Australias Curriculum Dilemmas
State Cultures and the Big Issues
Edited by
Lyn Yates, Cherry Collins and Kate OConnor
MELBOURNE UNIVERSITY PRESS
An imprint of Melbourne University Publishing Limited
187 Grattan Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia
mup-info@unimelb.edu.au
www.mup.com.au
First published 2011
Text Lyn Yates, Cherry Collins and Kate OConnor, 2011
Design and typography Melbourne University Publishing Limited, 2011
This book is copyright. Apart from any use permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 and subsequent amendments, no part may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted by any means or process whatsoever without the prior written permission of the publishers.
Every attempt has been made to locate the copyright holders for material quoted in this book. Any person or organisation that may have been overlooked or misattributed may contact the publisher.
Text design by Phil Campbell
Typeset by J&M Typesetting
Printed by Griffin Press, South Australia
National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry
Yates, Lyn, 1949-
Australias curriculum dilemmas: state cultures and the big issues/Lyn Yates, Cherry Collins and Kate OConnor.
9780522857726 (pbk.)
9780522860122 (epub)
9780522857702 (pdf)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
EducationCurriculaAustralia.
TeachingAustralia.
Education and stateAustralia
Educational planningGovernment policyAustralia.
Other Authors/Contributors: Collins, C. W. (Cherry Wedgwood), OConnor, Kate.
370.994
Contents
Lyn Yates, Cherry Collins and Kate OConnor
Lyn Yates
3 The influence of curriculum pasts on curriculum futures: A South Australian case study
Alan Reid
Penny Andersen and Karin Oerlemans
Jack Keating
Cherry Collins and Lyn Yates
7 The senior secondary curriculum in NSW: Academic traditions face issues of retention
Margaret Vickers
Jim Dellit
Rob Gilbert
Cherry Collins
Graham S. Maxwell and J. Joy Cumming
Bill Hannan
Bridget Leggett and Robyn White
Jenni Connor
Colin Marsh
Geoff Riordan
Lyn Yates, Cherry Collins and Kate OConnor
Editors
Lyn Yates is Foundation Professor of Curriculum at the University of Melbourne, Australia, where she is also Pro Vice-Chancellor (Research). Lyn has a background in history, sociology and philosophy and a longstanding interest in the different ways academic disciplines, professionals and policy see curriculum and its problems and possibilities, beginning with her 1987 PhD on Curriculum Theory and Non-sexist Education. Her publications include The Education of Girls: Policy, Research and the Question of Gender (1993); What Does Good Education Look Like? Situating a Field and its Practices (2004); and Making Modern Lives: Subjectivity Schooling and Social Change (with Julie McLeod, 2006). She recently (with Michael Young) edited a special issue of the European Journal of Education (vol. 45, no. 1, 2010) on Knowledge, Globalisation and Curriculum and (with Madeleine Grumet), the 2011 World Yearbook of Education Curriculum in Todays World (Routledge).
Cherry Collins is a Principal Research Fellow at the University of Melbourne. She has previously held positions in Education at Deakin University, the Australian Council for Educational Research, Murdoch University, the University of Canberra and, while a graduate student, at Harvard University. In Canberra she was a member of the ACT Schools Authority and chaired its Curriculum Standing Committee. In Perth she was a member of the Curriculum Standing Committee of the WA Secondary Education Authority. Her past publications include Competencies: the Competencies Debate in Australia (Australian College of Education 1993), Curriculum Stocktake: evaluating school curriculum change (Australian College of Education 1995), Gender and School Education (with M. Batten, J. Ainley and C. Getty, AGPS 1996) and Factors Influencing the Educational Performance of Males and Females in School and their Initial Destinations after Leaving School (with J. Kenway and J. McLeod, Commonwealth of Australia, 2000).
Kate OConnor is a research assistant in the University of Melbourne Graduate School of Education. She completed an honours thesis in Public Policy and Management on discourses and implementation issues arising from debates concerning the Australian history curriculum in 2007 and has published an article on classifying postgraduate curriculum scholarship in the Australian Educational Researcher. She has worked as a policy officer in the Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations and at the University of Melbourne and was the project officer for the ARC funded Discovery Project School Knowledge, Working Knowledge and the Knowing Subject: A Review of State Curriculum Policies 19752005.
Acknowledgements
This book emerged from a research project funded by the Australian Research Council, entitled School Knowledge, Working Knowledge and the Knowing Subject: A Review of State Curriculum Policies 1975 2005. Additional support was given by the Melbourne Graduate School of Education, which enabled Kate OConnor to continue work on this project through the important writing phase. We are grateful to both the ARC and the MGSE for the funding and in kind support that made this book possible.
Over the course of the project, a number of different people have contributed. Brenda Holt in 2007 and Katie Wright in 2008 were instrumental in getting the project under way, researching literature and organising interviews, and establishing the project website. Both Katie and Brenda brought clarity and efficiency and flair to the work of making the project happen, and provided insights and a great deal of ongoing support to Lyn and Cherry.
During the project we received much assistance, good will and commitment to the task of making Australian curriculum history more visible from a number of people, in particular Bill Green and Stephen Kemmis from Charles Sturt University who were instrumental in organising and participating in seminars around the issues that are taken up in the project; and May Leckey, a colleague at MGSE who was working on history curriculum. Appy Laspagis from the Education Resource Centre at University of Melbourne gave invaluable advice about sources. In sourcing curriculum materials, we want to acknowledge support from librarians and the collections of the NSW Teachers Federation Library, the University of South Australia library, the SSABSA library, and the WA Curriculum Council, and further assistance from Jim Tunstall, Lyn Tonkin, Joelie Hancock, Tony Mercurio and Ann Shilling. Making decisions about relevant key curriculum documents for our lists proved to be a quite difficult task, and we thank Denise Neal, Colin Marsh, Alan Reid, Jenni Connor, Rob Gilbert, Radhika Gorur, Jack Keating, Graham Maxwell, Margaret Vickers, Jim Tunstall, and Geoff Riordan who kindly gave feedback on the draft lists.