Christopher Nuttall - The Invasion of 1950

For those of us who are part of the Alternate History Community (and I certainly consider myself a member) Operation Sea Lion the planned German invasion of Britain in 1940 seems to hold a promise of a radical shift in the balance of European power. Had Hitler invaded, had Britain fallen, the Nazis would seem to hold supreme power. Hitler would have been able to go east in 1941 without having to worry about his rear, while Japan and Italy would rapidly have snapped up the remains of the British Empire. It would be a total geopolitical disaster.

Fortunately, the Nazis would have faced formidable problems in carrying out the invasion, to the point where most members of the AH Community dismiss it as a pipe dream. In my opinion, Sea Lion had about a one-in-six chance of success; Hitler, still a calculative gambler in 1940, decided that it was too big a risk to take.

But what if the invasion had been launched later?

It wasnt, of course. Hitlers forces bogged down in Russia, Hitler declared war on the United States in a fit of absentmindedness and Germany was crushed between the combined forces of America, Britain and Soviet Russia. The war ended in 1945.

But what if Hitler had won in Russia? What if America hadnt entered the war?

Would they plan to invade Britain again?

This book was written several years ago and has been heavily edited (no less than three people looked at it.) However, it may not be up to the standards of my current projects. As always, comments and editing notes are welcome.

In addition, I have tried to keep the use of German phrases down to the bare minimum, as they tend to annoy me when I see them in other books.

England, 1943

No, Winston Churchill said.

Winston, be reasonable, Anthony Eden said. The Leader of the House of Commons stared down at the Prime Minister. We have been fighting for four years. The country is tired of fighting with no prospect of victory.

Churchill felt a hot flash of anger. Anthony, Hitler and his madmen must be stopped, he said, remembering bitter disappointments when the Japanese had headed north into the Soviet Union and the United States had drifted back into isolation. Were the only people holding the line!

The Germans captured Stalingrad a month ago, Lord Halifax said. Churchill nodded slowly, unsurprised that his old competitor had joined the delegation. It wont be long before they start to press into Iran, and as you know, we have had a most imprudent communication from the Shah. He said that unless we evacuate his country the Russian forces having gone to die in the defence of Stalingrad already his forces will turn on ours with German support.

Churchills eyes drifted to the map hed placed the wall. German forces, having taken Moscow back in 1941, had concentrated on securing their flanks before advancing down towards Stalingrad and the oil wells to the south of the city and Iran. The Soviet Union the remains of the Soviet Union, under Beria wasnt able to stop them. The Foreign Ministry was privately predicting that the remains of the USSR would fall apart all too soon. Churchill had met Beria, hed dealt with the man and he had no illusions about his allys capabilities. Stalins death had taken the heart out of the Russian resistance.

Hed hoped that Wavell would produce victories in the Western Desert, but even that had turned sour in his mouth as Hitler sent more and more resources into the desert and then Rommel had taken them to create a new puppet state in Egypt, for the Italians. The British held the line at the Suez Canal, but both sides knew that it would only be a matter of time before Rommel tried to cross the waterway, or the Arab-Jewish fighting in Palestine rendered the British position untenable. They all knew, now, what fate Hitler had in mind for the Jews and when the British position collapsed, the Jews would flee or try to fight.

Beria has already declared his intention to attempt to reach a diplomatic solution with the Germans, Halifax pressed. If he settles for the status quo, he will surrender literally millions of souls, and unthinkable wealth in terms of land and resources. Hitler will be able to switch his forces back to the west, or he will be able to head into Iran and through Iran into Iraq or India.

Churchill frowned at him. The preservation of the Empire and the defeat of Adolph Hitler are my first priorities, he said, coldly. If Hitler wins in this war, the world will be plunged into barbarism.

Clement Attlee, Leader of the Opposition and Deputy Prime Minister, coughed. Winston, you have concentrated on winning, or at least fighting, the war, and we respect you for it, he said. However, our country is on the verge of internal collapse. The treasury is effectively bankrupt. The Empire is simply not supplying us with the resources we need to keep afloat. If it were not for the credit line the Americans have extended us, we would have been forced to seek terms before now.

His voice darkened. We sit here and talk about war on a global scale, he continued. Throughout England, the real victims of the war struggle to provide us with war materials and food, fearing only that their agonies will never end. As Germany brings the farmland in the Ukraine under their control, the German capability for continuing the war indefinitely will only expand, while our own ability to maintain even the current level of mobilisation will fall. I have heard of rumours of planned strikes, even riots, in protest at the recent cuts in rations. Frankly, Winston, Britain is on the verge of collapse.

And even if we win, what have we gained? It will be a world without Hitler, but a world where we will have lost the Empire, a world where we cannot feed our children or even protect their interests, he asked. Can we, now, hope to defeat Germany on our own? The Soviet Union is a dead beast now and our armies are incapable of carrying the war to Germany. The war cannot be won. The best we can do is not lose.

Churchill met his eyes. When I became Prime Minister, there was no suggestion that we should seek a peace with that most untrustworthy little man, he said, altering the facts slightly. There had been some secret discussions, which had come to nothing, between the Nazis and some of their British supporters. If Hitler was a reasonable man, a man we could do business with, we could come to some arrangement. We cannot trust him to keep an agreement with us any longer than is convenient to him.

The war cannot be won, Eden said flatly.

Churchill looked at him. Is that the opinion of the House of Commons?

Yes, Lord Halifax said.

I will not seek a peace with Germany, Churchill said. He allowed his voice to sharpen. This small delegation could only mean one thing. Am I to assume that you intend to remove me if I refuse to seek a dishonourable peace?

The country is at stake, Eden said, guilt written on his features. Churchill wasnt surprised. Eden was a competent Foreign Secretary, but he had no spine. There is no choice left but to seek a peace agreement with Hitler, at least to find out what he will let us keep.

Churchill rose ponderously to his feet. In that case, gentlemen, I will see the King immediately and offer my resignation, he said. In fact, as the great and the good of England have refused to allow me to continue my policy, I see no choice, but to insist on my immediate resignation from the post of Prime Minister.

Oddly enough, for the first time in far too long, he felt free.

He smiled at their faces. But mark my words, my friends, he said. We have not finished with Hitler, nor has he finished with us. This is not peace, but an armistice, to be broken when