T his book is respectfully dedicated to the late Dan Shideler, the man who made it possible.
I didnt get to meet Dan until late in the first decade of the 21st Century, though Id been reading his work for years before. It was his idea for us to collaborate on something for FW Media, and the next thing I knew, I had a contract for the first volume of the Greatest Handguns book.
He would have edited this second volume had he lived long enough, but tragically, he and his encyclopedic knowledge of firearms were both taken from us altogether too soon.
Dan, it all workedand wherever you are, youre the one to thank for these books being in print. Thank you, Brother, and Godspeed.
FOREWORD
A few years ago Massad Ayoob caught up with me and settled down to the task of convincing me that I surely was becoming bored with nothing to do. (The fact that he was sitting on the other side of my office desk at the time and he could not see me behind the towering piles of paper thereon was not considered.) To this day I am convinced that I could have slowly gotten to my hands and knees and crawled out of my officeand he would never have known that I was gone. With the benefit of hindsight I should have done just that, because by continuing to hang around I found myself agreeing to author the needed Foreword for his soon-to-be-published book, Massad Ayoobs Greatest Handguns of the World.
Dave Brennan, right, discusses Glock .40s with Mas Ayoob.
As I recall, Mas kept insisting that I had a moral obligation to do so, since I was the one who had originally suggested the idea to him. Obviously I have not yet learned to keep my big, fat mouth shut in life.
Fast forward to the present day. The book, upon its publication, promptly became a brisk seller. Indeed here at Precision Shooting magazine we sold bunches of them. It wasnt hard to sell them, admittedly. Mas did a great job of writing the 288 full size pages of text and the supporting color photography was of equal quality. And the handguns chosen for coverage were the best of the best of the last one hundred or so years. There were Pythons, Combat Magnums, Highway Patrolmen, Colt Woodsmen, S&W Models 36, 27, M&Ps, Colt Model 1911s (of course) and probably a dozen or so more. For many of its readers it was Old Time Week, as they renewed their memories of long gone days and long gone firearms, both never to return.
Fast forward, again, to the present day. The publisher has decided to go ahead with Volume II, which will, not surprisingly, carry the same title as the first. Another 15 or 20 new guns will be featured, for which there simply was not room in the first book. And for the 841 callers who just had to complain to someone about the absence of the S&W Model 57 (the .41 Magnum) in the first volumehere, here, dry those tears and stop snifflingwe swear that its in the second volume, and weve given it extra space, just to make it up to you.
And when I heard about the second volume forthcoming I mumbled to myself I wonder what turkey hes going to get to write the Foreword for this one?
Dave Brennan
Editor
Precision Shooting magazine
Manchester, CT
INTRODUCTION
W elcome to Volume II and if you bought Volume I, thank you, because the good sales of that one were the reason this one was commissioned.
A whole lot of chapters scheduled for the first one didnt make it when we ran out of room. Editor Dan Shideler wanted to make it more visual with more and bigger pictures, and that left less space for words.
There was an angry thread at www.sigforum.com which took me to task for not mentioning the SIG-Sauer series as among the greatest. Alas, that had been one that wound up on the cutting room floor after Volume I. It is, most certainly, here in Volume II.
Some at www.coltforum.com were shocked that a book with the words Greatest Handguns in the title did not include the Colt Single Action Army. When we had to cut some out, we decided to keep a twentieth century focus, so the SAA was deferred to the book we hoped would follow if reader interest warrantedthe book you are now reading.
Both of those chapters appeared originally in Dave Brennans magazine, The Accurate Rifle. So did several of the other chapters appearing here. The Thompson/Center chapter originally appeared in American Handgunner magazine, and is reprinted here courtesy of editorial director Roy Huntington. Some chapters, including those on the Mauser C96, the Colt Pocket Model, and the .41 Magnum, were written expressly for this book.
Criteria were simple enough: Did the gun in question make a difference? The Colt Peacemaker, the Gun That Won the West, obviously qualifies; the qualifications of some others were less obvious. Sometimes, the difference was limited to a relatively narrow field of users, as with the High Standard Supermatic. There were good .22 target pistols before and after it. Yet, the Supermatic ushered in the age of a .22 auto engineered for super accuracy, and equipped with quick change barrels that delivered modularity and flexibility without sacrificing precision grouping capability. (Yes, the S&W Model 41 had that toobut it came later. The High Standard gets the credit for establishing the concept.)
The Colt Pocket Hammerless set the stage for one of the most widely produced genres of handgun the world has ever seen, the flat little .32 and .380 carry autos. The .41 Magnum never met the expectations of popularity that heralded its arrival in 1964but the reasons why it didnt make it an important case study in how ebbs and flows in trends and forces outside the gun design room can influence firearm trends and sales. And then, there are handguns such as the Mauser C96, whose effects can reach far, far beyond the world of the hand-held firearm.
I had a great time researching this material, research that spans several decades. It was a labor of love. I hope you get just as much enjoyment out of reading it.
Massad Ayoob
October, 2011
CHAPTER