The Impact of the Presidency of Donald Trump on American Jewry and Israel
The Jewish Role in American Life
An Annual Review of the Casden Institute for the Study of the Jewish Role in American Life
The Impact of the Presidency of Donald Trump on American Jewry and Israel
The Jewish Role in American Life
An Annual Review of the Casden Institute for the Study of the Jewish Role in American Life
Volume 19
Steven J. Ross, Editor
Steven F. Windmueller, Guest Editor
Lisa Ansell, Associate Editor
Published by the Purdue University Press for
the USC Casden Institute for the Study of the
Jewish Role in American Life
2021
University of Southern California
Casden Institute for the
Study of the Jewish Role in American Life.
All rights reserved.
Production Editor, Marilyn Lundberg Melzian
Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images.
US President Donald Trump stands on stage after his address to the Israeli American Council National Summit 2019 at the Diplomat Beach Resort in Hollywood, Florida, on December 7, 2019.
Hardcover ISBN: 978-1-61249-708-2
Paperback ISBN: 978-1-61249-709-9
ePUB ISBN: 978-1-61249-710-5
ePDF ISBN: 978-1-61249-711-2
Published by Purdue University Press
West Lafayette, Indiana
www.press.purdue.edu
Printed in the United States of America.
Contents
Gary Phillip Zola
Michael Berenbaum
Morton A. Klein and Elizabeth A. Berney, Esq.
Adam Basciano and Shanie Reichman
Saba Soomekh
Gilbert N. Kahn
Ehud Eiran
Rob Eshman
Mark Mellman
Matthew Brooks and Shari Hillman
Dan Schnur
Steven F. Windmueller
Foreword
We are still at an early point in making any full assessment of the presidency of Donald J. Trump. It is not too early, however, to make some preliminary observations about the impact his four years in office has had on American Jews and Israel. The writers assembled here were contacted two years ago by volume editor Steven Windmueller and represent voices across the political spectrum, ensuring that the relationship between the Trump presidency and American Jews is presented from a wide cross-section of opinion and analysis.
Since assuming the directorship of the Casden Institute six years ago, my goal has been to create programs and publications that shed light, not heat, on topics at the forefront of American Jewish culture and identity. To that end, we have assembled a volume that presents a multitude of viewpoints ranging from staunch Trump defenders to equally staunch Trump critics. Our contributors include academics, journalists, lobbyists, activists, and pollsters who represent a spectrum of opinions on the 45th presidents impact on the national and international level. We asked only one thing from our authors: write what you wish but treat those on the other side of your argument with respect. I believe we have achieved this goal and it is my hope that our readers will appreciate the diversity of views that makes this a truly unique publication.
I wish to thank our volume editor, Steven Windmueller, for the hard work he has put in assembling such an impressive array of voices willing to write critically about the last four years. My thanks also go to Marilyn Lundberg Melzian, our wonderful longtime volume production editor.
Steven J. Ross
Myron and Marian Casden Director
Deans Professor of History
Editorial Introduction
by Steven F. Windmueller
Any effort that seeks to unpack a unique political moment in time, even as this period is still unfolding, represents a significant challenge. This book is precisely about capturing a particular phenomenon, Donald Trumps impact on the American political story and the US-Israel relationship. His counter-cultural performance reflected his uniqueness, as his Presidency would uproot many of core norms and practices of contemporary politics. His American nationalism would run counter to the traditions of American political culture in the post-Second World War era. Nor is Trumps imprint complete as he continues to be a force both within the Republican Party and beyond. His politics have unleashed a new style of activism and behavior that is likely to have a significant impact on the American political psyche well beyond his presence.
In many ways this book project represents a snapshot in time as we try to unravel the imprint of a President on our nation in general, and more directly its Jewish community. Each of the contributors to this venture came to the project with a particular perspective and that is as it should be, for surely Donald Trump leaves no one without a defining judgment.
I am grateful to the Casden Institute, its director Professor Steven J. Ross and to its associate director Lisa Ansell, for their willingness to tackle this controversial and complex subject matter and their personal encouragement and support in completing this initiative. Similarly, I am particularly appreciative to Purdue University Press, its director, Justin C. Race, graphic
Christopher J. Brannan, and especially to copyeditor, Marilyn Lundberg Melzian of USC, for their professional guidance and input.
Our writers represent a diversity of viewpoints. Accordingly, our goal was to identify the multiplicity of voices that reflected the range of reaction both inside the Jewish community and from Israel in connection with the 45th President.
My appreciation extends to each of these individuals for offering their reflections and insights. Together this volume, I believe, represents some of the primary thinking about the Trump Presidency.
American academics such as Michael Berenbaum, Gilbert Kahn, Dan Schnur, Saba Soomekh, and Gary Zola provide their respective insights on this four-year time frame, drawing from their distinctive disciplines and their respective research expertise. Employing modern Jewish history, Professor Berenbaum explores this President against the backdrop of anti-Semitism, the Shoah, and other defining contemporary moments, while offering a deeply personal perspective on the Trump Presidency. Dr. Gilbert Kahn adds the important dimension of the distinctive role played by American Jewish Orthodoxy in connection with this President. Dr. Saba Soomekh, who combines her expertise as a communal professional with her social science and academic credentials, introduces some critical observations about how Donald Trump was received by an array of different Jewish audiences, including the Persian community. Professor Dan Schnur, a prominent columnist and academic, shares some insights on how this Presidency played out for independent voters. My HUC colleague, Professor Gary Zola shares an important and insightful historical perspective in connection with our 45th President.
Israeli political scientist, Ehud Eiran, adds his own particular orientation as he explores the unique and significant relationship that this President enjoyed with the State of Israel and with Israeli society.
Indeed, the particular contribution of Mark Mellman, one of this nations most prominent political researchers and public opinion experts, adds an additional important layer of statistical and analytical data to this conversation.
The Forwards National Editor, Rob Eshman, provides a journalistic assessment of how this President was covered, analyzed and understood by the Anglo-Jewish media.