Bennett Laura J. - In search of a better world: lectures and essays from thirty years

IN SEARCH OF
A BETTER WORLD

Titles by Karl Popper
available from Routledge

THE OPEN SOCIETY AND ITS ENEMIES VOLUME I

THE OPEN SOCIETY AND ITS ENEMIES VOLUME II

THE POVERTY OF HISTORICISM

THE LOGIC OF SCIENTIFIC DISCOVERY

CONJECTURES AND REFUTATIONS

UNENDED QUEST

THE SELF AND ITS BRAIN (with J. C. Eccles)

THE OPEN UNIVERSE

QUANTUM THEORY AND THE SCHISM IN PHYSICS

REALISM AND THE AIM OF SCIENCE

KNOWLEDGE AND THE BODY-MIND PROBLEM

THE MYTH OF THE FRAMEWORK

THE LESSON OF THIS CENTURY

THE WORLD OF PARMENIDES

ALL LIFE IS PROBLEM SOLVING

IN SEARCH OF
A BETTER WORLD

Lectures and essays from thirty years

Karl Popper

Translated by Laura J. Bennett,
with additional material by Melitta Mew.
Translation revised by Karl Popper and Melitta Mew.

First published in English in 1994

by Routledge

11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE

Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada

by Routledge

a division of Routledge, Chapman & Hall, Inc.

29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001

First published in paperback 1996

Reprinted 1998, 2000

Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group

1984, 1992 Karl Popper, 1996 Estate of Karl Popper

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers.

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book has been requested

ISBN 0415087740 (hbk)

0415135486 (pbk)

CONTENTS

For a translation of this title, please see the footnote on page 171.

A Summary by Way of a Preface

All things living are in search of a better world.

Men, animals, plants, even unicellular organisms are constantly active. They are trying to improve their situation, or at least to avoid its deterioration. Even when asleep, the organism is actively maintaining the state of sleep: the depth (or else the shallowness) of sleep is a condition actively created by the organism, which sustains sleep (or else keeps the organism on the alert). Every organism is constantly preoccupied with the task of solving problems. These problems arise from its own assessments of its condition and of its environment; conditions which the organism seeks to improve.

An attempted solution often proves to be misguided, in that it makes things worse. Then follow further attempts at solutions further trial and error movements.

We can see that life even at the level of the unicellular organism brings something completely new into the world, something that did not previously exist: problems and active attempts to solve them; assessments, values; trial and error.

It may be supposed that, under the influence of Darwins natural selection, it is the most active problem solvers, the seekers and the finders, the discoverers of new worlds and new forms of life, that undergo the fastest evolution.

Each organism also strives to stabilize its internal conditions of life and to maintain its individuality an activity whose results biologists call homoeostasis. Yet this too is an internal agitation, an internal activity: an activity that attempts to restrict the internal agitation, a feedback mechanism, a correction of errors. The homoeostasis must be incomplete. It must restrict itself. Were it completely successful, it would mean the death of the organism, or, at the very least, the temporary cessation of all its vital functions. Activity, agitation, search are essential for life, for perpetual restlessness, perpetual imperfection; for perpetual seeking, hoping, evaluating, finding, discovering, improving, for learning and for the creation of values; but also for perpetual error, the creation of negative values.

Darwinism teaches that organisms become adapted to the environment through natural selection. And it teaches that they are passive throughout this process. But it seems to me far more important to stress that the organisms find, invent and reorganize new environments in the course of their search for a better world. They build nests, dams, little hills and mountains. But their most momentous creation has probably been the transformation of the atmosphere surrounding the earth by enriching it with oxygen; this transformation was, in turn, a consequence of the discovery that sunlight can be eaten. The discovery of this inexhaustible food supply and of the countless ways of trapping the light created the kingdom of plants; and the discovery that plants can be eaten created the animal kingdom.

We ourselves have been created by the invention of a specifically human language. As Darwin says (The Descent of Man, ), the use and development of the human language reacted on the mind itself. The statements of our language can describe a state of affairs, they can be objectively true or false. So the search for objective truth can begin the acquisition of human knowledge. The search for truth, particularly in the natural sciences, no doubt counts among the best and greatest things that life has created in the course of its long search for a better world.

But have we not destroyed the environment with our natural science? No! We have made great mistakes all living creatures make mistakes. It is indeed impossible to foresee all the unintended consequences of our actions. Here science is our greatest hope: its method is the correction of error.

I do not want to end this preface without saying something about the success of the search for a better world during the eighty-seven years of my life, a time of two senseless world wars and of criminal dictatorships. In spite of everything, and although we have had so many failures, we, the citizens of the western democracies, live in a social order which is better (because more favourably disposed to reform) and more just than any other in recorded history. Further improvements are of the greatest urgency. (Yet improvements that increase the power of the state often bring about the opposite of what we are seeking.)

I would like to mention briefly two things that we have improved.

The most important one is that the terrible mass poverty which still existed in my childhood and in my youth has now disappeared. (Unfortunately, this is not the case in places like Calcutta.) Some may object that there are people in our society who are too rich. But why should that bother us, if there are sufficient resources and the good will to struggle against poverty and other avoidable suffering?

The second is our reform of the criminal law. At first we may have hoped that if punishments were lessened, then crime would also lessen. When things did not work out like this, we nonetheless decided that we ourselves, individually and collectively, would rather suffer the effects of crime, corruption, murder, espionage and terrorism, than take the very questionable step of trying to eradicate these things by means of violence, and so run the risk of turning innocent people into victims. (Unfortunately, it is difficult to avoid this completely.)

Critics accuse our society of corruption in high places, although they may admit that corruption is sometimes punished (Watergate). Perhaps they are not aware of the alternative. We prefer an order that guarantees full legal protection even to evil criminals so that they are not punished in cases where there is doubt. And we prefer this order to another order in which even those who are innocent of any crime cannot find legal protection and are punished even when their innocence is undisputed (Solzhenitsyn).