Tad R. Callister - A Case for the Book of Mormon

The primary purpose of this book is to present a case for the Book of Mormonboth intellectually and spiritually. In so doing, I have highlighted many evidences of the Book of Mormons divine authenticity and its remarkable capacity to influence our lives for good. In addition, I have responded to many criticisms made against the Book of Mormon and addressed many of the fallacies underlying those arguments.

To accomplish these purposes, I have drawn from books and talks I have previously published, as well as unpublished talks and further research on the subject. Hopefully, this consolidates in one place an analysis of the Book of Mormon that can be rewarding both intellectually and spiritually.

It is hoped that the evidences presented will (1) further strengthen the testimony of those who already believe the Book of Mormon to be true, (2) help resolve issues for those who may have some honest questions about its divine origin, (3) provide insights for those who seek answers for their family members and friends who have been or may be exposed to false claims against the Book of Mormon, (4) stimulate the interest of those who have not yet feasted upon its profound doctrine and witness of Christ, and (5) give the critics pause to reconsider the Book of Mormon as God-given.

Although some evidences cited here refer to particular locations in the Americas, there is no intended endorsement of any specific location where the Book of Mormon people may have lived.

While I have received helpful suggestions from many in the creation of this book, a special thanks goes to my wife, Kathy, who has prayed for me, reviewed multiple manuscripts, given me many valuable insights, and encouraged me every step of the way.

Also, a special thanks goes to my assistant, Kathy Densley, who has cheerfully typed numerous copies of the manuscript and given helpful input in that process. Also, thanks to Jacquie Noriega, who has helped on occasion with the typing.

Brian Hansbrow and Ted Barnes have made multiple reviews of the manuscript as it was in progress, given invaluable suggestions on style and substance, and painstakingly reviewed and prepared numerous footnotes.

I also want to thank the many others who have meticulously reviewed the manuscript and contributed much in terms of factual accuracy, rationale, and editing, and have made many other practical and spiritual suggestions: Jeremy T. Callister, Lynn C. Callister, Reed R. Callister, Richard T. Callister, Wayne Christofferson, Devin G. Durrant, Keith A. Erekson, Matthew J. Grow, Richard G. Hinckley, Kerry Hull, Larry R. Lawrence, Laurel Lawrence, David B. Marsh, Elder James B. Martino, Carol F. McConkie, Curtis Oscarson, Virginia H. Pearce, Elder Kevin W. Pearson, Neal Rappleye, Linda S. Reeves, Elder Michael T. Ringwood, Matthew P. Roper, Michael Skinner, and John W. Welch. Without the help of these people, this book would not have been possible.

I also express my appreciation to Book of Mormon Central and FairMormon, and their respective staffs, who have provided invaluable research into the Book of Mormon.

Finally, thanks to the team at Deseret Book who have worked to make this book a reality. Lisa Roper has ably overseen the project from its earliest stages. Emily Watts, who has excellent editing skills, has provided many suggestions that have been most helpful. Heather Wards design, Richard Ericksons art direction, and Rachael Wards meticulous typesetting have created a pleasing look and feel for the book.

Although I have tried to accurately state the facts and present correct doctrine, this is my own work, and if there are errors, they are mine.

Chapter 1

A Book for All Seasons

The Book of Mormon is a book for all seasons. It is for all men and all women of all nations and races. If we are lonely or discouraged, its words can soothe our wounded soul[s] (Jacob 2:8). If we feel the stain of sin or guilt, it can lead us to the Saviors cleansing powers. If our testimonies are wavering, it can shore them up. If we have been incorrectly influenced by the philosophies of men, it can restore the truth. And if we desire to become more like Christ, it can be our spiritual catalyst. Whatever our circumstance or need, it can provide us with a remedy of superior healing power. It is Gods divine gift to every soul who wants to return to Him and become more like Him.

The Book of Mormon Still Stands

Metaphorically, the Book of Mormon has been in the boxing ring of critical analysis for almost two hundred years. It has been through fifteen rounds of analyzing, critiquing, and criticizing, but never a knockdown has occurred. It is an invincible opponent that knows no compromise. It carries no white flag. Rather, it is resolute and unapologetic in its claim that it is a divine work of God.

Hugh Nibley, one of the great scholars of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (also referred to in this book as the Church), made this observation about the Book of Mormon: The outrageous daring of its title page is the very thing that should whet the appetite of a real scholar: here is a book that is asking for a fight, so to speak, and if it is as flimsy as it looks at first glance any competent schoolman should have little trouble polishing it off in an hour or so. Ironically, however, the hours have turned into days, the days to months, the months to years, and the years to decades, and yet the Book of Mormon still standsa formidable foe that cannot be ignored or conquered.