THE BUILDING BLOCKS OF THE EARLIEST GOSPEL
A ROAD MAP TO EARLY CHRISTIAN BIOGRAPHY
By Arthur J. Bellinzoni
THE BUILDING BLOCKS OF THE EARLIEST GOSPEL
A Road Map to Early Christian Biography
Copyright 2018 Arthur J. Bellinzoni. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in critical publications or reviews, no part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without prior written permission from the publisher. Write: Permissions, Wipf and Stock Publishers, W. th Ave., Suite , Eugene, OR 97401 .
Wipf & Stock
An Imprint of Wipf and Stock Publishers
W. th Ave., Suite
Eugene, OR 97401
www.wipfandstock.com
paperback isbn: 978-1-5326-4356-9
hardcover isbn: 978-1-5326-4357-6
ebook isbn: 978-1-5326-4358-3
Manufactured in the U.S.A.
All translations of the Gospel of Mark are my own. All other biblical references are from The Harper Collins Study Bible: New Revised Standard Version. New York: Harper Collins Publishers, 1989 .
Bellinzoni invites study groups on a splendid journey, preparing them for informed discussion of the multiple sources and story forms used by the Gospel of Marks author. Understanding their use helps us distinguish what are Jesus authentic teachings, historical facts, and teachings of the nascent church. Readers are invited to struggle with Marks deeper meaning in order to hear his proclamation of the good news, summed up in Jesus commandment to love God and ones neighbor.
Nancy Lane , Reverend Mother, Life-Professed Solitary
In his latest book, Bellinzoni accomplished for me what five years of study at a main-line theological seminary did notto pull together into a coherent whole all I knew, supposed and doubted on the subject. His method is rigorous while crystal clear, at the end culminating in a graceful, even moving summary of what he takes to be the evangelists method and motive.
Turhan Tirana , Reverend Father
With intellectual rigor and heartfelt passion for the text, Arthur Bellinzoni gives his audience what he has always offered to his students: a chance to let the text speak first in its own context. What follows is a journey toward faith for seekers and a fresh perspective for pastors, engaging mind and spirit. Deep faith is nurtured by good information. Through this unique insight into Marks view of Jesus we are enriched and challenged.
Virginia Miner , Transitional General Presbyter, Presbytery of Lackawanna, Scranton, Pennsylvania
Bold, Informative, DeepBellinzoni combines decades of scholarships to produce a systematic analysis of the first Christian gospel. He conclusively proves that Mark was a compilation of earlier written texts and that this gospel was not meant to be an unbiased historical account. Like many powerful sermons, the writer of Mark calls upon historical facts, but also myths and ethical sayings to promote Jesus as the messiah. Bellinzonis work is a must for serious students of the bible!
Rick McLain , PhD, Professor at State University of New York, Ononodaga Community College
PREFACE
A s an undergraduate at Princeton University, I first developed a special interest in the Gospel of Mark. I wrote my two-semester senior thesis for my religion major under the guidance of Professor W. D. Davies on The Gospel of Mark in Recent Scholarship ( 1957 ). I was convinced at the time that Mark was the earliest gospel and that, as such, it was closer in time to Jesus and, therefore, more reliable in the quest for the historical Jesus. That is still partially true: the Gospel of Mark is certainly our earliest written gospel, but the issue of its historical value is far more complicated, as we will see in this volume.
My interest in the Gospel of Mark persists, even after sixty years. After the publication of my comprehensive study The New Testament: An Introduction to Biblical Scholarship (Eugene, Oregon: WIPF & STOCK, 2016 ), I vowed that my writing days were behind me. That delusion lasted for about two weeks, until I felt compelled to write a book that would introduce the average layperson to the probable process that resulted in the Gospel of Mark. I wanted to afford the reader some understanding of the building blocks of the gospel, the presumably oral and largely written material to which the evangelist had access and which he wove into a literary narrativea story.
A friend of mine recently remarked it would be wonderful if someone could write a book about the Bible that could bridge some of the differences between more conservative and more liberal Christians. I had this challenge very much in mind in writing this book, but I am not really confident it is possible to build such a bridge because conservative and liberal Christians probably start out with different assumptions about what the Bible is and what it is not. I do not believe the Bible is inerrant, perfect in every detail, even in the original Hebrew and Greek, and certainly not in any English translation. If anything, I might say the Bible is perhaps something more like The Word of God in the words of men.
My interest in the Gospel of Mark persists to this day. The fact that Mark is the earliest gospel may mean it has the least-developed theology and that it, therefore, reflects a more primitive and less-developed christology than the gospels of Matthew, Luke, and John. Clearer access to that less-developed Christianity may, in itself, be of merit.
I like to believe people will use this volume as a basis for discussionchurch groups, seminarians, college students, reading groups, etc. I hope to introduce my readers to questions for which we do not know all of the answers in order to generate thinking and conversation.
Although I am ultimately responsible for everything in this book, I have been assisted by two good friends whose contributions I want to acknowledge. Dr. Marvin A. Breslow, Emeritus Professor of History at the University of Maryland and my roommate for four years at the Harvard University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, read the manuscript and made innumerable corrections and invaluable suggestions. Only I can appreciate the value of his contribution. Dimitrios Dimopoulos contributed his technical skills in ways that were invaluable. I can barely type, no less unravel the intricacies of a computer for formatting, correcting, printing, and copying such a long manuscript. Both mens contributions are evident on almost every page of this book.
ABBREVIATIONS
Scripture Abbreviations
Old Testament
GenGenesis
ExodExodus
LevLeviticus
NumNumbers
DeutDeuteronomy
JoshJoshua
JudgJudges
Sam Samuel
- Kgs- Kings
Chr Chronicles
JobJob
Ps ( pl Pss)Psalms
ProvProverbs
IsaIsaiah
JerJeremiah
LamLamentations
EzekEzekiel
DanDaniel
HosHosea
JoelJoel
AmosAmos
MicMicah
HagHaggai
ZechZechariah
MalMalachi
New Testament
MattMatthew
MarkMark
LukeLuke
JohnJohn
ActsActs
RomRomans
- Cor- Corinthians
GalGalatians
EphEphesians
ColColossians
Thess Thessalonians
HebHebrews
JasJames
RevRevelation
Apocrypha
WisWisdom of Solomon
Macc Maccabees
Pseudepigrapha
Sib OrSibylline Oracles
Ezra Ezra
Esd Esdras
Bar Baruch
En Enoch
Ps SolPsalms of Solomon
Dead Sea Scrolls