Allan J. Lichtman - The Case for Impeachment

Above all I would like to thank the light of my life, my wife, Karyn Strickler, for her patience and invaluable help. I would also thank those who contributed significantly to this book: Amanda Brower, Jake Assail, Rebecca Brenner, Scott Vehstedt, Dan Ballentyne, John Schmitz, and Sam Lichtman. Special thanks go to my outstanding agent, Bridget Matzie, my superb editor, Julia Cheiffetz, and the incredible team at HarperCollins that made this book possible.

Predicting the Next President:

The Keys to the White House

FDR and the Jews

(with Richard Breitman)

White Protestant Nation:

The Rise of the American Conservative Movement

Prejudice and the Old Politics

Thirteen Keys to the Presidency

Your Family History:

How to Use Oral History, Personal Family Archives,

and Public Documents to Discover Your Heritage

Australia

HarperCollins Publishers (Australia) Pty. Ltd.

Level 13, 201 Elizabeth Street

Sydney, NSW 2000, Australia

www.harpercollins.com.au

Canada

HarperCollins Canada

2 Bloor Street East - 20th Floor

Toronto, ON M4W 1A8, Canada

www.harpercollins.ca

New Zealand

HarperCollins Publishers New Zealand

Unit D1, 63 Apollo Drive

Rosedale 0632

Auckland, New Zealand

www.harpercollins.co.nz

United Kingdom

HarperCollins Publishers Ltd.

1 London Bridge Street

London SE1 9GF, UK

www.harpercollins.co.uk

United States

HarperCollins Publishers Inc.

195 Broadway

New York, NY 10007

www.harpercollins.com

Impeachment will proceed from the misconduct of public men, or, in other words, from the abuse or violation of some public trust, and they relate chiefly to injuries done immediately to the society itself.

Alexander Hamilton, The Federalist, 1788

I began thinking about impeachment before the November 2016 election. For weeks, my students had been asking who I thought would be our next president, Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump. Finally, on a late evening in mid-September 2016, I leaned back in my chair and peered out into the hall at the mostly darkened offices of American University in Washington, D.C. I had just finished my analysis: Donald Trump would win the presidency. My forecast ignored polls, debates, advertising, tweets, news coverage, and campaign strategiesthe usual grist for the punditry millsthat count for little or nothing on Election Day. I had used the same proven method that had led me to forecast accurately the outcomes of eight previous elections, and Id kept my eye on the big picturethe strength and performance of the party holding the White House currently. After thirty-two years of correctly forecasting election results, even I was surprised by the outcome.

Among those who noticed my prediction was Donald J. Trump himself. Taking time out of preparing to become the worlds most powerful leader, he wrote me a personal note, saying, ProfessorCongratsgood call. What Trump overlooked, however, was my next big prediction: that, after winning the presidency, he would be impeached.

Here I did not rely on my usual model, rather I used a deep analysis of Trumps past and proven behavior, as well as the history of politics and impeachment in our country. In the short span of time between Trumps election and this books publication in April 2017, his words and deeds have strengthened the case considerably. History is not geometry and historical parallels are never exact, yet a president who seems to have learned nothing from history is abusing and violating the public trust and setting the stage for a myriad of impeachable offenses that could get him removed from office.

Americas founders, who had so recently cast off the yoke of King Georges tyranny, granted their president awesome powers as the nations chief executive and commander in chief of its armed forces. Yet they understood the dangers of a runaway presidency. As James Madison warned during the Constitutional Convention, the president might pervert his administration into a scheme of peculation or oppression and betray his trust to foreign powers, with an outcome fatal to the Republic. To keep a rogue president in check, delegates separated constitutional powers into three independent branches of government. But knowing that a determined president could crash through these barriers, they also put in place impeachment as the rear guard of American democracy.

After exhaustive debate, the framers agreed on broad standards for impeachment and assigned this absolute power not to the judiciary, but to elected members of the U.S. House and Senate. By doing so they ensured that the fate of presidents would depend not on standards of law alone, but on the intertwined political, practical, moral, and legal judgment of elected officials. Hamilton explained that impeachments broadly cover the abuse or violation of some public trust and are properly denominated POLITICAL.

This book will escort you through the process and history of impeachment; as your warning about the dangers of Trumps rogue presidency; and as your guide to the myriad transgressions that I predict will lead to his impeachment. I invite you to follow each chapter and decide for yourself when Trump has reached the critical mass of violations that triggers the implosion of his presidency.

In The Case for Impeachment, Ill look beyond the daily news cycle of events which will have continued to evolve to focus on the big picture of the impeachment process and the Trump presidency. Ill take you through constitutional debates and the gritty politics of past impeachments. Ill explain how Trump threatens the institutions and traditions that have made American safe and free for 230 years, and Ill make clear why a Republican Congress might impeach a president of its own party. I also include a personal memo to President Trump on how he might dispel the clouds of controversy overhanging his presidency and avoid impeachment. I am not calling here for a witch hunt against an unconventional presidency or for snaring Trump on some minor or technical violation. The point is to assess at what point impeachment becomes necessary to protect Americas constitutional liberties and the vital interests of the nation. An impeachment of a president need not imperil the institution of the presidency. The genius of impeachment, said historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr. is that it could punish the man without punishing the office.

The impeachment of an American president is rare, but not exceptional. The U.S. House of Representatives has impeached two presidents, Andrew Johnson in 1868 and Bill Clinton in 1998; another, Richard Nixon, only averted impeachment with a timely resignation. Counting Nixon, one out of every fourteen U.S. presidents have faced impeachment. Gamblers have become rich betting on longer odds than that.

But forget historical odds. Trump has broken all the usual rules of politics and governing. Early in his term, he has stretched presidential authority nearly to the breaking point, appointed cabinet officials dedicated to destroying the institutions they are assigned to run, and pushed America toward legal and constitutional crises.

No previous president has entered the Oval Office without a shred of public service or with as egregious a record of enriching himself at the expense of others. Trumps penchant for lying, disregard for the law, and conflicts of interests are lifelong habits that will permeate his entire presidency. He has a history of mistreating women and covering up his misdeeds. He could commit his crime against humanity, not directly through war, but indirectly by reversing the battle against catastrophic climate change, upon which humanitys well-being will likely depend. His dubious connections to Russia could open him to a charge of treason. His disdain for constitutional restraints could lead to abuses of power that forfeit the trust of even a Republican Congress.