• Complain

Donald Kagan - The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War

Here you can read online Donald Kagan - The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War full text of the book (entire story) in english for free. Download pdf and epub, get meaning, cover and reviews about this ebook. City: Ithaca/London, year: 1989, publisher: Cornell University Press, genre: History. Description of the work, (preface) as well as reviews are available. Best literature library LitArk.com created for fans of good reading and offers a wide selection of genres:

Romance novel Science fiction Adventure Detective Science History Home and family Prose Art Politics Computer Non-fiction Religion Business Children Humor

Choose a favorite category and find really read worthwhile books. Enjoy immersion in the world of imagination, feel the emotions of the characters or learn something new for yourself, make an fascinating discovery.

Donald Kagan The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War
  • Book:
    The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War
  • Author:
  • Publisher:
    Cornell University Press
  • Genre:
  • Year:
    1989
  • City:
    Ithaca/London
  • Rating:
    4 / 5
  • Favourites:
    Add to favourites
  • Your mark:
    • 80
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5

The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War: summary, description and annotation

We offer to read an annotation, description, summary or preface (depends on what the author of the book "The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War" wrote himself). If you haven't found the necessary information about the book — write in the comments, we will try to find it.

The first volume of Donald Kagans acclaimed four-volume history of the Peloponnesian War offers a new evaluation of the origins and causes of the conflict, based on evidence produced by modern scholarship and on a careful reconsideration of the ancient texts. He focuses his study on the question: Was the war inevitable, or could it have been avoided?Kagan takes issue with Thucydides view that the war was inevitable, that the rise of the Athenian Empire in a world with an existing rival power made a clash between the two a certainty. Asserting instead that the origin of the war cannot, without serious distortion, be treated in isolation from the internal history of the states involved, Kagan traces the connections between domestic politics, constitutional organization, and foreign affairs. He further examines the evidence to see what decisions were made that led to war, at each point asking whether a different decision would have been possible.

Donald Kagan: author's other books


Who wrote The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War? Find out the surname, the name of the author of the book and a list of all author's works by series.

The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War — read online for free the complete book (whole text) full work

Below is the text of the book, divided by pages. System saving the place of the last page read, allows you to conveniently read the book "The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War" online for free, without having to search again every time where you left off. Put a bookmark, and you can go to the page where you finished reading at any time.

Light

Font size:

Reset

Interval:

Bookmark:

Make
Abbreviations and Short Titles
ACLAntiquit Classique
AHRAmerican Historical Review
AJAAmerican Journal of Archaeology
AJPAmerican Journal of Philology
ASIE. Badian, ed., Ancient Societies and Institutions
ATLB. D. Meritt, H. T. Wade-Gery, and F. M. McGregor, The Athenian Tribute Lists
BSAProceedings of the British School at Athens
Beloch, GG2K. J. Beloch, Griechische Geschichte, 2nd ed.
Bengtson, GGH. Bengtson, Griechische Geschichte, 2nd ed.
Busolt, GGGeorg Busolt, Griechische Geschichte
Busolt and Swoboda, GSGeorg Busolt and Heinrich Swoboda, Griechische Staatskunde
CAHCambridge Ancient History
CPClassical Philology
CQClassical Quarterly
CRClassical Review
CWClassical World
De Sanctis, SdG.Gaetano De Sanctis, Storia dei Greci
FGrHF. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker
Glotz and Cohen, HGGustave Glotz and Robert Cohen, Histoire Grecque, II
Gomme, Hist. Comm.A. W. Gomme, A Historical Commentary on Thucydides
GroteGeorge Grote, A History of Greece
HSCPHarvard Studies in Classical Philology
IGInscriptiones Graecae
JHSJournal of Hellenic Studies
LCLLoeb Classical Library
Meyer, ForschungenEduard Meyer, Forschungen zur alten Geschichte, II
Meyer, GdAEduard Meyer, Geschichte des Altertums
PACAProceedings of the African Classical Association
PWPauly-Wissowa and others, Realenzyklopcidie der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft
Riv. di fil .Rivista di filologia e di istruzione classica
SEGSupplementum Epigraphicum Graecum
SIGW. Dittenberger, Sylloge Inscriptionum Graecarum
TAPATransactions of the American Phililogical Association
TodM. N. Tod, A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions to the End of the Fifth Century
Appendixes
A. The Willingness of the Members of the Delian League to Accept Athenian Leadership

()

In the fourth century the same opinion was held not only by Isocrates ( De Pace 30, Paneg. 72, Panath. 67), who might have been prejudiced in favor of Athens, but also by the Spartans, who, according to Xenophon ( Hell. 6. 5. 34), admitted that the Athenians had been chosen for naval leadership by the allies with the approval of the Spartans. Aristotle ( Ath. Pol. 23. 2) has seemed to some scholars to argue against Spartan approval by saying that the Athenians took over the hegemony , and they have tried to emend the text to remove the difficulty. Gomme ( Hist. Comm., I, 272) is probably right in arguing against emendation and interpreting the phrase, Sparta being unwilling to keep the leadership. It is clear in any case that the official Spartan position was one of at least tacit approval. If Aristotles text is sound and to be interpreted in the more obvious way, then Aristode may be taking the opinion of the recently defeated war party to be the true attitude of the Spartans.

Meyer ( Historia, XII [1963], 405 ff.) has seized upon the statement of Herodotus . [ A] (8. 3), as the cornerstone of his theory that the formation of the Delian League was the culmination of an Athenian plan dating back at least to 481. His arguments are not convincing, but there is no reason to deny that by 478 the Athenians were more than willing to assume the leadership. Herodotus emphasizes their willingness, while Thucydides lays great stress on the initiative of the allies. Both may be right. As Sealey says: This difference of judgment and other such oddities doubtless reflect contemporary controversies. He goes on to say that the student who tries to reconstruct fifth-century history from fifth-century sources is in the position of a foreigner who visits a country and listens to citizens talking politics; at best a tenth of what he hears will be true. This last statement seems to me altogether too pessimistic. Thucydides and Herodotus were not merely two citizens discussing politics; they were learned men who had taken some pains to discover the facts. Their interpretations are not to be too readily discarded.

B. The Historicity of Diodorus Account of the Spartan Assembly in 475

()

Many modern scholars simply omit this story, presumably for the same reasons that Busolt denies its historicity ( GG, III: 1, 71, n. 1). For him, Die ganze Beratung ist augenscheinlich nur ein Erzeugnis der Phantasie des Ephoros. Grote ( A History of Greece [4th ed.; London, 1872] IV, 348, n. 1) accepts the conference and considers the role played by an influential Spartan named Hetoemaridas probable enough but like Busolt, he considers the speech merely an Isocratean commonplace invented by Ephorus. With what I hope is the higher naivet of this century, I believe in the conference, the decisive presence of Hetoemaridas, the general tenor of his remarks, and even in the accurate recollection of his words by the Spartan source of Ephorus. There is no doubt that Ephorus knew many true things that neither Herodotus nor Thucydides reports. In this period, which falls outside the main interest of both historians, the argument from silence is worthless. It is bad method to ignore the report of an ancient author that is not contradicted by another source, internally impossible, or self-contradictory. Thus, there is no reason to doubt the conference. It is impossible to imagine why Ephorus or his source should invent Hetoemaridas and attribute a leading role to him, for we know nothing else about him. So we should not doubt him or his important intervention in the discussion.

A. Andrewes ( ASI, 45) accepts the historicity of the meeting and the role of Hetoemaridas without question. The speeches, of course, like all speeches reported by ancient historians, are more suspicious and probably are not completely accurate reports of what the speakers said. Nonetheless, in this case I think Ephorus is reporting the general idea of the discussion correctly and even passes on some of the more striking phrases used by the speakers. The young men of the war party urged in favor of their unwillingness to give up rule of the sea an ancient oracle in which the god had warned them against a lame hegemony ( ). To abandon one of the two foundations of their leadership, they argued, would leave Sparta lame indeed. I believe this rare burst of eloquence became famous among the Spartans and was often repeated. Little more than a decade later, Cimon, the greatest philolaconian in Athens, who had named one of his sons Lacedaemonius, who admired Sparta and its way of life, and who had very close relations with Sparta, was called upon to argue in behalf of sending an Athenian expedition to help Sparta. He responded with unaccustomed eloquence, exhorting the Athenians not to leave Hellas lame nor see their city deprived of its yokefellow ( E ) (Plut. Cim. 16. 8). It appears that he put to good use in a different context a metaphor that he had heard from his Spartan friends. For an excellent discussion of the value of Ephorus-Diodorus as a source, see Mary Morse Fuqua, A Study of Character Portrayal in the History of Thucydides, unpublished doctoral dissertation Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y., 1965, 1018.

Next page
Light

Font size:

Reset

Interval:

Bookmark:

Make

Similar books «The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War»

Look at similar books to The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War. We have selected literature similar in name and meaning in the hope of providing readers with more options to find new, interesting, not yet read works.


Reviews about «The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War»

Discussion, reviews of the book The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War and just readers' own opinions. Leave your comments, write what you think about the work, its meaning or the main characters. Specify what exactly you liked and what you didn't like, and why you think so.