THERE IS A DIVIDE in the Democratic Party, but its not between supporters of Hillary Clinton and those of Bernie Sanders. Its also not the establishment versus outsiders. Those who persist with that dichotomy arent just fostering unnecessary enmity between natural allies but are clinging to a simplistic plot line that has more in common with fake news than actual reality.
So what is this existing divide among Democrats? Its between those who oppose Trump and those who resist him and his regime. That may seem like trivial semantics, but its actually a distinction with a huge difference.
In politics, the opposition assumes that the ruling powers are legitimate, and that their group or faction represents a democratic minority of public opinion. The loyal opposition acts as a check against the tyranny of the majority, as John Adams once wrote, counterbalancing the powers of the ruling regime. The opposition intentionally differentiates itself from the majority, with the hope of building support for its values and objectives among the populace; but it can also find strategic opportunities to work and compromise with the majority in pursuit of the national good.
In normal times, thats what the losing party doesoppose the legitimate, democratically elected winner.
These are not normal times. Donald Trump is not the legitimate president of the United States, thus opposition is insufficient. Relentless resistanceusing any lawful actions to stymie, harass, delay, and obstructis the only option.
Democracy For Me, But Not For Thee
At this point, the electoral math has been well studied and combed over: Trump received nearly three million fewer votes than the popular winner of the election, Hillary Clinton. The Electoral Collegean antiquated system designed to protect the property rights of slave ownerselevated the loser to office. It is the second time this century that this immoral, irrational, and undemocratic system has crowned an unworthy ignoramus and undermined our democratic values as a nation. And we clearly didnt learn anything from the debacle that was George W. Bush, since here we are again.
Of course, the deep flaws in our democracy arent limited to the White House. In the Senate, the 48 Democrats in the minority have received, collectively, 23 million more votes than the 52 Republicans in the supposed majority. Why do the Dakotas, with their combined population of 1.6 million, have four senators, while California, population 38.8 million, has two? Why does Wyoming, with a population of 584,000, have two senators while Washington, DC, population 659,000, has zero?
The situation is no better in the House of Representatives, which is so heavily gerrymandered by Republicans that Democrats would have to win the House national popular vote by over eight points just to have an even-odds chance of retaking the chamber!
Our republican (lowercase r) form of government is entirely predicated on the notion of proportional representation, but our current system is neither proportional nor representative.
During the 2016 campaign, Trump repeatedly complained that the system was riggedand he was right! By any standards of democratic fairness, our system for electing presidents and members of Congress is objectively rigged to maintain Republican control of government. As our national demographics shift to increasingly multicultural urban valuesand away from rural white conservative valuesthis rigging threatens to further undermine the legitimacy of our democracy.
Block The Vote
Those antiquated, built-in institutional advantages Republicans enjoy prove we arent living in a legitimate democracy. But even with those undemocratic structural flaws, Republicans still cant win elections in a fair voteand so they engage in systematic voter suppression efforts, designed to reduce voting by people of color, women, and young voters.
Its no accident that Trumps victory hinged on narrow margins in Wisconsin, Michigan, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania. After GOP takeovers in the 2010 Republican wave, all four states systematically weakened organized labora key component of the Democratic electoral machine. They also made it harder for urban votersa key component of the Democratic electoral coalitionto cast their votes through such mechanisms as strict voter ID laws and the reduction of polling stations in communities of color and college towns. As giddy Wisconsin Republican state senator Mary Lazich crowed after the passage of that states voter ID law, Hey, weve got to think about what this would mean for the neighborhoods around Milwaukee and the college campuses.
And yet, those institutional and electoral advantages were still not enough. In the months leading up to the 2017 election, an entire ecosystem of fake news sites sprang up to distribute a special brand of crazy. Meanwhile, Republican officials reportedly met with the Russian intelligence agencies later accused of causing damage to Democratic campaigns. As we write this, more than a handful of high-level Trump administration officials and Republican operatives are under investigation for colluding with Russia during the election. Meanwhile, as if all this werent absurd enough, the FBI director leaked information on the bogus Hillary Clinton email investigation, while keeping mum about the FBIs investigations into the Trump campaigns Russian ties.
When the dust settled, after running the most hateful, xenophobic, racist, sexist, and anti-Semitic campaign in American history, and despite losing by any reasonable, democratic measure, were to accept that Donald Trump won?
Sorry, but no.
We cannot accept the results of an illegitimate election won by an illegitimate candidate by illegitimate means. And as such, Democrats and progressives cannot consider ourselves the opposition, opposite the petty tyrants and pennyweight dictators who rule todays GOP. Remember, opposition lends legitimacy to their illegitimate gains. An opposition crafts counterarguments in the hopes of gaining a seat at the negotiating table and rallies its supporters behind the idea that next time well get more votes.
We already got more votesand would have won even more had it not been for the Republican cheating. That makes us the majority. And yet, here we are, ruled by a tyranny of the minority that cheated us out of our deserved democratic victory.
We are not the opposition. We are the resistance .