César Aira - Dinner

My friend was home alone, but he invited us over for dinner anyway; he was a very sociable man liked to talk and tell stories, though he wasnt any good at it; hed get the episodes mixed up, leave effects without causes and causes without effects, skip over important parts, and drop anecdotes right in the middle. This didnt bother my mother, who at her age had reached a level of mental confusion equivalent to what my friend had been born with; I think she didnt even notice. In fact, she was the one who most enjoyed the conversation that evening it was the only thing she did enjoy because the names of the towns families were being constantly mentioned magic words that distilled her entire interest in life. I listened to the names drop, as one listens to the falling rain, whereas for her, each was a treasure full of meanings and memories. Mother was enjoying something that was lacking in her daily conversation with me; in that respect, and in that one alone, she and my friend were perfectly in sync. He was a building contractor, and for decades hed been building houses in Pringles, so he knew the configurations and genealogies of all the towns families one name conjured another, driven by the townspeoples lifelong practice of pursuing their entire intellectual and emotional education by talking about one another. It would have been difficult to do this without names. Its true that things get lost with age and arterial sclerosis, and they always say that names are the first to go. But names are also the first things to be found, for their search is carried out through other names. They started to talk about a woman, the daughter of what was her name? Miganne, who lived in front of Cabanillas office Which Cabanillas? The one married to Artolas daughter? And they continued in this vein. Each name was a knot of meaning into which many other chains of names converged. The stories crumbled into a hailstorm of names and were left unsolved, like old crimes, swindles, betrayals, or scandals involving these families had also been left unsolved. To me, the names meant nothing, they had never meant anything, but that wasnt why they didnt sound familiar. On the contrary, they did sound familiar; I would say they were the most familiar things in the world, because Id been hearing them since my earliest childhood, from before I could talk. For some reason though, I had never been able, or had never wanted, to associate those names with faces or houses; perhaps this was my way of rejecting the life of the town where I had, nonetheless, spent my entire life, and now, age and the loss of names, had created the curious paradox of losing what I had never had. Even so, when I heard them on the lips of my mother and my friend, each rang out like a chime of memories, empty memories, sounds.

It wasnt as if I were devoid of real memories, full-fledged memories, a fact I ascertained after dinner when my friend showed us an old windup toy, which he removed from a glass display cabinet. It was small, barely larger than the palm of his hand, and was a pretty faithful miniature of an old-fashioned bedroom, complete with a bed, a bedside table, a rug, a wardrobe, and a door at the foot of the bed, which, without a wall to open out from, looked like a second wardrobe and was outfitted with a rectangular box, which I assumed hid one of the characters. Another character was in plain sight, lying on the bed: a blind old woman, partially reclining against some cushions. The floor of this room was neither tile nor parquet but rather made of smooth, dark planks, like the floors of the houses in Pringles that I remembered from childhood. I took special notice of it because it made me think of the house of two seamstresses where my mother used to take me when I was little. I have one very strange memory associated with that house. Once, when we went there, the floor was missing from the room where the seamstresses were working, that is a large part of it had been removed for renovations, or had caved in; the entire room was one great big pit, very deep, with dark gullies full of crumbling dirt and rocks, and water at the bottom. The seamstresses, and their assistants and customers, were all around the edges. Everybody was laughing and talking about the catastrophe and offering explanations. Its one of those inexplicable memories that remains from early childhood. I dont think it was as extreme as I remember, because nobody can live or work in a place like that, but I was very small maybe thats why the pit looked so big to me. I once asked Mother if she remembered it because it is still so vivid. Not only didnt she remember the pit in the seamstresses room, she didnt even remember the seamstresses. I was irrationally annoyed that she didnt remember, as if she were forgetting on purpose. The fact was, she had no reason to remember such a trivial event from sixty years before. But she was intrigued, and she turned the subject over in her mind for an entire day. I had only one fact that might have helped her: one of the seamstresses had a finger that was hard and stiff, like wood. Based on this finger, which I could picture very clearly, I thought I could recall its owner, an old woman with dark brown hair in a stiff hairdo, tall and skinny, with strong bones; her finger was enormous. Needless to say, this detail didnt help at all. My mother asked: Could they be the Adurizes, the Razquines, the Astuttis? It exasperated me that shed try to get at it through names, which didnt mean anything to me. My names were the pit, the finger, things like that, which didnt have names. I didnt insist. I kept the memory to myself, as I had so many others. My first memory, the first memory in my life, is also of an excavation: the street we lived on was dirt, and then they paved it, and to do so they had to dig up a lot of dirt and rocks; I remember the whole street divided up into rectangular pits, like graves, I dont know why, because I dont think you have to make a grid like that in order to pave a street.

These recurrent memories of pits, so primitive and maybe purely fantastical, had maybe come to symbolize holes in memory, or rather holes in stories, ones that not only dont exist in the stories I tell but that I am always filling up in stories others tell me. I find fault in everybody elses narrative art, almost always with good reason. My mother and my friend were particularly deficient in this respect, perhaps because of their passion for names, which prevented the stories normal development.

It was truly magical: names came to their lips with enormous facility and in abundant quantities. Did so many people now live or had so many people ever lived in Pringles? Any excuse would suffice for them to conjure up a whole new bunch of names. Those whod lived on the block. Those whod moved away from the block. Those whod lost money on their houses. Those who grew aromatic herbs. These last came up after my friend began to praise the meal, which led to the story of how he had obtained the fresh sage for the rice. Packaged sage wasnt any good it lost most of its aroma during the drying process. And his own sage plants had been accidentally destroyed a few days before during one of his frequent house renovations or additions. So, that afternoon he had gone out to pay visits to some acquaintances whom he knew had herb gardens. He had no luck at the first place: their sage had been contaminated with toxic dust; maybe he could wash it well and use it but it wouldnt be worth it if anyway hed have to worry about it being poisoned. I asked if theyd used some kind of insecticide. No, something much worse! Delia Martnez, that was her name, never used any chemicals in her garden. The name, which didnt mean anything to me, roused my mother out of her silence. Delia Martnez, the one whos married to Liuzzi? The one who lived on the Boulevard? Yes, thats the one. I noticed that habit of calling women by their maiden names: it was like constantly bringing up peoples histories. Mother said she had run into her the day before and had heard all about her agonizing ordeal with the statue My friend interrupted her: that was precisely what had contaminated her sage plants, and her other herbs, and the whole garden. They explained taking for granted that I didnt know that this woman lived in front of the small plaza along the Boulevard, where for months a sculptor had been working on a monument commissioned by the city. The marble dust blew toward her house, forcing her to live with her doors and windows hermetically sealed, and covered every last leaf in her garden, which was her great passion and her lifes masterwork. Shed complained to the mayor and on the local radio and television stations. Looking worried and peering down at her half-eaten dinner, Mother said that marble dust was very bad for your health. That was news to me, and it sounded like nonsense, so I started to say something, anything that would serve as an excuse for my friend in case he had used that sage, but he was already emphatically agreeing with her: it was the worst thing in the world, a poison, it could even kill you. And he should know, because of his profession. Of course he hadnt taken sage from Delias garden! Anyway, she never would have given him any under those conditions. No, the sage that flavored the rice we were eating came from elsewhere. Delia Martnez herself had referred him on. The person with the sage was Mrs. Gardey, the owner of Pensin Gardey. A beauty! my mother exclaimed, and then she began, willy-nilly, to praise the woman, who, according to her, was still beautiful at ninety; in her youth she had been crowned Miss Pringles, and she was beautiful on the inside as well as on the outside: so good, kind, sweet, and intelligent a real contrast to all the mean women in town. My friend nodded distractedly and ended the story by saying that when he went to see her, the old woman had greeted him by saying that she didnt have any rooms available, that she was very sorry but the wedding of some French landowners had brought many people to town (some from France), and she was fully booked; when he explained why hed come, she went to get some scissors, led him to her garden in the back, and cut him some sage, not without first offering him a guided tour of her establishment. My mother: the pension, its so beautiful, so well cared for, so clean, when she was young she always went to the carnival balls the late Mr. Gardey would organize. My friend corrected her: it wasnt the same building But Mother was sure of what she was saying, she argued with him forcefully, and enthusiastically elaborated upon her memories. But it simply wasnt so, my friend knew exactly what he was talking about and silenced her with his own more precise information: the old Pensin Gardey, one of the most prominent buildings in town, had been demolished, and the current one a much more modest and architecturally dull building had been built on the same site. There was no question about the accuracy of what he was saying because there had been a trial that had reached epic proportions. It all happened when the owner of the adjacent lot, which was vacant, wanted to build. When he examined the maps in the lands registry, he discovered that the people who had built the pension had made a mistake and erected the dividing wall beyond the legal boundary, four inches into his the neighbors property. This was a serious problem: Gardey was not allowed to purchase that strip, usurped inadvertently, for land couldnt be partitioned into plots less than a yard wide, and any offer of monetary compensation was contingent on the good will of the one accepting. There were arguments, misunderstandings, and the whole thing ended up in court; the neighbor was intransigent, and since the law was on his side, the pension, that fantastic Beaux Arts palace, the pride of the town and the site of the most wonderful memories for those whod attended the grand carnival balls, had to be torn down all because of four lousy inches! At this point, in the middle of the story, my friend stretched out his hand and held his thumb and index finger apart (four inches apart). This had been the ruin of Gardey, who was a good man; the neighbor was the bad one, all of Pringles blamed him. Gardey died soon thereafter, a bitter man, and it was his wife who rebuilt the pension and had been running it for the last several decades.