Addy Pross - What is Life?: How Chemistry Becomes Biology

WHAT IS LIFE?

By formulating a new stability kind in nature, Addy Pross has uncovered the chemical roots of Darwinian theory, thereby opening a novel route connecting biology to chemistry and physics. That connection suggests that abiogenesis and biological evolution are one process, throwing exciting new light on the origin of life and offering a striking chemical explanation for lifes unusual characteristics. This book is more than worth readingit stirs the readers mind and paves the way toward the birth of further outstanding ideas.

Ada Yonath, joint winner of the Nobel Prize for Chemistry, 2009

HOW CHEMISTRY BECOMES BIOLOGY

ADDY PROSS

Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom

Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the Universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries

Addy Pross 2012

The moral rights of the author have been asserted

First Edition published in 2012

Impression: 1

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above

You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available

Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Data available

ISBN 9780199641017

Printed in Great Britain by
Clays Ltd, St Ives plc

To Nella, Guy, and Tamar, for what my life is

I spent the afternoon musing on Life. If you come to think of it, what a queer thing Life is! So unlike anything else, dont you know, if you see what I mean.

PG Wodehouse

The subject of this book addresses basic questions that have transfixed and tormented humankind for millennia, ever since we sought to better understand our place in the universethe nature of living things and their relationship to the non-living. The importance of finding a definitive answer to these questions cannot be overstatedit would reveal to us not just who and what we are, but would impact on our understanding of the universe as a whole. Has the universe been fine-tuned to support life, as implied by proponents of the so-called anthropic principle? Or, to take a more Copernican view of mans place in the universe, is the human race just a chemical scum on a moderate-sized planet, as argued by Stephen Hawking, the noted physicist? A wider conceptual gulf would be hard to conceive.

Some 65 years ago another renowned physicist, Erwin Schrdinger, wrote a book whose catchy title What is Life? directly addressed the issue. In the opening lines of that book Schrdinger wrote:

How can the events in space and time which take place within the spatial boundary of a living organism be accounted for by physics and chemistry? The preliminary answer can be summarized as follows: The obvious inability of present-day physics and chemistry to account for such events is no reason at all for doubting that they can be accounted for by those sciences.

Sixty-five years have passed but despite the enormous advances in molecular biology in those years, illuminated by a long list of Nobel prizes, we continue to struggle with Schrdingers simple and direct question. And a struggle it is. Carl Woese, one of the leading biologists of the twentieth century, has recently gone as far as to claim that the state of present-day biology is reminiscent of that of physics at the turn of the twentieth century, before Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr, Erwin Schrdinger, and the other great twentieth-century physicists totally revolutionized the subject; that the time for biologys revolution has finally come. Strong sentiments indeed! What is no less remarkable is that modern biology appears to be happily meandering along its current mechanistic path with most of its practitioners indifferent, if not oblivious, to the shrill cry for reassessment.

Yes, it is true that in this modern era we know unequivocally that there is no lan vital, that living things are made up of the same dead molecules as non-living ones, but somehow the manner in which those molecules interact in a holistic ensemble results in something very specialus, and every other living thing on this planet. So, paradoxically, despite the profound advances in molecular biology over the past half-century, we still do not understand what life is, how it relates to the inanimate world, and how it emerged. True, over the past half-century considerable effort has been directed into attempts to resolve these fundamental issues, but the gates to the Promised Land seem as distant as ever. Like a mirage in the desert, just as the palm trees signalling the oasis seemingly materialize, shimmering on the horizon, they fade away yet again, leaving our thirst to understand unquenched, our drive to comprehend unsatisfied.

So what is the basis of this deeply troubling and persistent dilemma? To clarify in simplest terms where the problem lies, consider the following hypothetical tale: you are walking through a field and you suddenly come across a refrigeratora fully functional refrigerator in a field with some bottles of beer inside, all nicely chilled. But how could a refrigerator be working in the middle of a field, apparently unconnected to any external energy source, yet maintaining a cold interior? And just what is it doing there, and how did it get there? You take a closer look and you see a solar panel on its top, which is connected to a battery, which in turn operates the compressor that all fridges have in order to function. So the mystery of how the refrigerator works is resolved. The refrigerator captures solar energy through the photovoltaic panel, so it is the sun that is the source of energy that operates the refrigerator and enables it to pump heat from cold to hotin the opposite direction to the one that normally governs heat flow. Thus, despite Natures drive to equalize the temperature inside and outside the cabinet, in this physical entity that we call a refrigerator, there exists a functional design that enables us to keep our food and drinks at a suitably low temperature.

But the mystery of how it got there in the middle of the field remains. Who put it there? And why? Now if I told you that no one put the refrigerator therethat it came about spontaneously through natural forces, you would react in total disbelief. How absurd! Impossible! Nature just doesnt operate like that! Nature doesnt spontaneously make highly organized far-from-equilibrium, purposeful entitiesfridges, cars, computers, etc. Such objects are the products of human designpurposeful and deliberate. Nature, if anything, pushes systems toward equilibrium, toward disorder and chaos, not toward order and function. Or does it?

The simple truth is that the most basic living system, a bacterial cell, is a highly organized far-from-equilibrium functional system, which in a thermodynamic sense mimics the operation of a refrigerator, but is orders of magnitude more complex! The refrigerator involves the cooperative interaction of, at most, several dozen components, whereas a bacterial cell involves the interaction of thousands of different molecules and molecular aggregates, some of enormous complexity in themselves, all within a network of thousands of synchronized chemical reactions. In the case of the fridge, the function is obviousto keep the beer or whatever else is in the cabinet cold by pumping heat from the cold interior to the hotter exterior. But what is the function of the bacterial cell with its organized complexity? Its function can be readily recognized simply by observing its action. Just as the function and workings of the refrigerator can be uncovered by inspecting its operation, so the cells functionits purpose if you likecan be revealed by seeing what it does. And what do we see? Every living cell is effectively a highly organized factory, which, like any man-made factory, is connected to an energy source and power generator that facilitates its operation. If the energy source is cut off the factory ceases to operate. This miniature factory takes in raw material, and through the utilization of power from the factorys power generator, converts those raw materials into the many functional components, which will then be assembled to produce the factorys output. And what is that output? What does this highly elaborate nano-factory produce? More cells! Every cell is ultimately a highly organized and efficient factory for making more cells! The Nobel biologist Francois Jacob expressed it rather poetically: the dream of every cell, to become two cells.