One of the best, most disturbing, and most powerful books about the shame that was/is Vietnam.
Minneapolis Star and Tribune
Its effect is as devastating as if its author had been killed. But he survived. So, through such writing, may the American language.
Times (London)
A genuine memoir in the full literary sense of that term, and a work that quickly established itself among Vietnam narratives as an exemplar of the genre. It recalls the depictions of men at war by Whitman, Melville, Crane, and Hemingway; and it stands at the same time in the central tradition of American spiritual autobiography as well, the tradition of Edwards and Woolman, of Franklin and Thoreau and Henry Adams.
Philip D. Beidler, American Literature and the Experience of Vietnam
OBrien writes with pain and passion on the nature of war and its effect on the men who fight in it. If I Die in a Combat Zone may, in fact, be the single greatest piece of work to come out of Vietnam, a work on a level with World War Twos The Naked and the Dead and From Here to Eternity!
Washington Star
OBrien brilliantly and quietly evokes the foot soldiers daily life in the paddies and foxholes, evokes a blind, blundering war. Tim OBrien writes with the care and eloquence of someone for whom communication is still a vital possibility. It is a beautiful, painful book, arousing pity and fear for the daily realities of a modern disaster.
Annie Gottlieb, New York Times Book Review
What especially distinguishes it is the intensity of its sketches from the infantry, an intensity seldom seen in journalistic accounts of the war.
Michael Casey, America
An admirable book by an admirable man a finely tuned, almost laconic account of soldiers at work.
Playboy
A controlled, honest, well-written account Mr. OBrien is educated, intelligent, reflective, and thoroughly niceall qualities that make his a convincing voice.
The New Yorker
Its a true writers job, gaining strength by dodging the rhetoric, and must be one of the few good things to come out of that desolating struggle.
Manchester Guardian
OBrien is writing of more than Vietnam. What OBrien is writing about is the military, and the feel of war, and cold fear, and madmen. OBrien does it with a narrative that often is haunting, and as clean as the electric-red path of an M-16 round slicing through the Vietnam dark.
Philadelphia Inquirer
A carefully made series of short takes, the honestly limited view of a serious, intelligent young man with a driving wish to be both just and brave. Its persistent tension is between contrary impulses: to fight well or to flee.
Geoffrey Wolff, Esquire
Its a beautiful book dealing with the unbeautiful subject of the Vietnam War. OBrien sees clearly and tells honestly. This may prove to be the foot soldiers best personal account of Americas worst war.
Penthouse
I wish Tim OBrien did not write so beautifully, for he makes it impossible to forget his book. I have read it three times, and years from now it will still have that terrible power to make me remember and to make me weep.
Gloria Emerson
Books by Tim OBrien
If I Die in a Combat Zone
Northern Lights
Going After Cacciato
The Nuclear Age
The Things They Carried
In the Lake of the Woods
Tomcat in Love
Names and physical characteristics of persons depicted in this book have been changed.
CONTENTS
lo maggior don che Dio per sua larghezza / fesse creando / fu de la volont la libertate
The Divine Comedy
Par. V, 19ff.
One
Days
I ts incredible, it really is, isnt it? Ever think youd be humping along some crazy-ass trail like this, jumping up and down like a goddamn bullfrog, dodging bullets all day? Back in Cleveland, man, Id still be asleep. Barney smiled. You ever see anything like this? Ever?
Yesterday, I said.
Yesterday? Shit, yesterday wasnt nothing like this.
Snipers yesterday, snipers today. Whats the difference?
Guess so. Barney shrugged. Holes in your ass either way, right? But, I swear, yesterday wasnt nothing like this.
Snipers yesterday, snipers today, I said again.
Barney laughed. I tell you one thing, he said. You think this is bad, just wait till tonight. My God, tonightll be lovely. Im digging me a foxhole like a basement.
We lay next to each other until the volley of fire stopped. We didnt bother to raise our rifles. We didnt know which way to shoot, and it was all over anyway.
Barney picked up his helmet and took out a pencil and put a mark on it. See, he said, grinning and showing me ten marks, thats ten times today. Count themone, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten! Ever been shot at ten times in one day?
Yesterday, I said. And the day before that, and the day before that.
No way. Its been lots worse today.
Did you count yesterday?
No. Didnt think of it until today. That proves todays worse.
Well, you shouldve counted yesterday.
We lay quietly for a time, waiting for the shooting to end, then Barney peeked up. Off your ass, pal. Companys moving out. He put his pencil away and jumped up like a little kid on a pogo stick. Barney had heart.
I followed him up the trail, taking care to stay a few meters behind him. Barney was not one to worry about land mines. Or snipers. Or dying. He just didnt worry.
You know, I said, you really amaze me, kid. No kidding. This crap doesnt get you down, does it?
Cant let it, Barney said. Know what I mean? Thats how a man gets himself lethalized.
Yeah, but
You just cant let it get you down.
It was a hard march and soon enough we stopped the chatter. The day was hot. The days were always hot, even the cool days, and we concentrated on the heat and the fatigue and the simple motions of the march. It went that way for hours. One leg, the next leg. Legs counted the days.
What time is it?
Dont know. Barney didnt look back at me. Four oclock maybe.
Good.
Tuckered? Ill hump some of that stuff for you, just give the word.
No, its okay. We should stop soon. Ill help you dig that basement.
Cool.
Basements, I like the sound. Cold, deep. Basements.
A shrill sound. A womans shriek, a sizzle, a zipping-up sound. It was there, then it was gone, then it was there again.
Jesus Christ almighty, Barney shouted. He was already flat on his belly. You okay?
I guess. You?
No pain. They were aiming at us that time, I swear. You and me.
Charlie knows whos after him, I said. You and me.
Barney giggled. Sure, wed give em hell, wouldnt we? Strangle the little bastards.
We got up, brushed ourselves off, and continued along the line of march.
The trail linked a cluster of hamlets together, little villages to the north and west of the Batangan Peninsula. Dirty, tangled country. Empty villes. No people, no dogs or chickens. It was a fairly wide and flat trail, but it made dangerous slow curves and was flanked by deep hedges and brush. Two squads moved through the tangles on either side of us, protecting the flanks from close-in ambushes, and the companys progress was slow.