The past books I have written all involved a great sports team or an individual athlete. All overcame great obstacles to rise to the top of their sport. It is hard to question a final score of a game or what an athlete accomplished. The idea of reasonable doubt of the events is never brought up. They either won the game, accomplished the goal, or not.
I was then asked to write this book on Kyle Unger and his wrongful conviction. It became a learning experience. A young teenager in a small community in Manitoba had been sexually assaulted and brutally slain. People wanted to find a murderer and so did I. It was easy to point the finger at Kyle Unger. He was accused of the murder, convicted of the crime, and spent fourteen years in jail. When I first looked into the case, I thought Kyle Unger was guilty. I like to think I dont jump to conclusions, but I did with Kyle Unger. Emotion took over my decision-making ability.
I almost said no to writing this book, but Im glad I didnt. I saw the real story emerge as I started to research the book. I saw how a justice system narrowed its focus on an individual and fit the evidence against him for the crime. In 1992, Kyle Unger was convicted of murder. A life was forever changed. That wrong was eventually made right. Unfortunately, the true murderer will never be convicted and punished for the crime.
This book will take the reader through the events around a murder, including the people involved, the investigation, and the trial. More importantly, the reader will see how the successful prosecution of Kyle Unger was eventually revealed to be a wrongful conviction. In 2009, he was acquitted of the crime.
Many people were affected negatively at every point during these events. But by the end of the story, it is possible for us to have a restored faith in Canadas justice system. During Kyle Ungers time in jail, the system evolved enough to right its previous wrongs against him. However, at the time of writing this book, there is an ongoing debate in Canada about the methods police forces use to gain confessions.
Chapter One Festival Weekend
It was the beginning of another Manitoba summer. A time for people to get outside before another winter set in. A time when every weekend held a new activity or adventure. For teenagers in the southeast, the summer of 1990 started with the Woodstick Music Festival in June. It was a two-day event held at the Birch Run ski resort near the town of Roseisle, located 120 kilometres southwest of Winnipeg. Most of the teenagers from the surrounding area would attend.
Sixteen-year-old Brigitte Grenier couldnt wait to leave her parents house in Miami. The Miami Collegiate grade 11 student was excited to attend her first concert. She wanted to hang out with friends, dance, and listen to music. She was a freckle-faced teenager with bright eyes and a pretty smile. People enjoyed her company and she was a popular student at school. They had just voted her to be the class president when school started back up in the fall. For now, she was heading up the graduation dance decorating committee. That celebration was scheduled for the week after Woodstick.
Brigitte was waiting for her best friend, Marlys Williment, to pick her up. They were going to the festival together, along with Marlyss boyfriend, Barry McTavish. Brigitte didnt have a boyfriend. But she knew there would be a lot of opportunities to meet boys at the festival. She had a personality that would easily attract them to her.
While Brigitte waited, her father joked about where she was going that night.
Shouldnt it be called Wood tick Festival, instead of Woodstick? teased Ron Grenier. He knew his youngest daughter didnt like wood ticks.
Brigitte stared at her father and then started to laugh.
Thats not funny, Dad.
Joking aside, Ron worried about his daughter going to the event. A lot of people were going to be there, and there would be drinking. And he had no way to protect her.
Dont worry, said Brigitte. I can take care of myself.
Soon after shed said that, her ride pulled up to the house. Brigitte said goodbye to her dad and got into the waiting car. The three friends drove out into the night, excited about what might happen. To them, it was going to be a great evening.
Chapter Two The Loners
Attending the Woodstick Music Festival was a spur-of-the-moment decision for nineteen-year-old Kyle Unger and his best friend, John Beckett. It was something for them to do on a Saturday night. There wasnt always much going on in rural Manitoba. They lived in the middle of the prairie. It was a large, empty landscape of crop fields criss-crossed by dirt roads and secondary highways. There were no tall buildings or the bright lights and excitement of a city. Most teenagers dreamed of the day when they could leave.
Kyle and John were considered loners. They didnt have many friends in the communities surrounding the town of Carmen, mainly just each other for the past three years. Unger, who wasnt originally from this part of Manitoba, was tall and thin with a scruffy moustache. He found it hard to make new friends. So, he did everything with John.
Some of Kyles problems making friends stemmed from his temper. He was kicked out of one school because of his unpredictable and violent behaviour. He had a reputation for being a troublemaker. Some people were afraid to be alone with him. All of this left a permanent mark on him. The shaggy, long-haired teenager was always an outsider.
On the night of June 23, 1990, they hitchhiked to the festival grounds. They looked like all the other teenagers in the crowd, wearing sneakers, jeans, and T-shirts. Their evening at Woodstick started around 8:30 p.m. Like most teenage boys attending the festival, they had a plan for the evening. It involved fun, getting drunk, and meeting girls.
There was a lot of room at the festival grounds. The main area was a large open field with the music stage at one end. People spread out over the rest of this area to sit, stand, and dance to the music being played on the stage.
The evening started with a game of football. Kyle and John joined in with a group of people they knew from school. For a short while, these loners were just two of the guys. When the game ended, they all sat and had beer together.
While they were playing football, Kyle had noticed Brigitte Grenier walk by. Hed always liked her at school. He had gone to Miami Collegiate with her. She was one of only a few classmates who hadnt thought he was weird. Hed always considered her his friend.
After a few beers with the football players, Kyle and John went out to find Brigitte. They found her with some friends near the front of the festival stage. Kyle was excited to see her. He sat down next to her and they started to talk.
It was a good time to catch up since Kyle had quit school the previous year. Hed gotten a job in Alberta and had only recently returned home to visit. He talked to her about Alberta. She filled him in on what was happening at school. John sat there, silent.
After twenty minutes of conversation, Kyle and John left to see what was happening around the festival. They eventually joined back up with the football crowd. Everybody was drinking heavily. Many were drunk, including Kyle and John.