Also by Sarah Miller
Violet and Daisy
The Miracle & Tragedy of the Dionne Quintuplets
The Borden Murders
Historical Notes
H Street in Washington, DC, has been renumbered since Mary Surratts time. Her boardinghouse, which in 1865 was number 541, is now number 604.
The original spelling, capitalization, and punctuation of quoted material have been preserved, except for a few instances that threatened to interfere with clarity. In those cases, silent corrections were made. When a discrepancy in the spelling of a witnesss name arose, I deferred to the spelling used in the trial transcripts for ease of reference.
Text copyright 2022 by Sarah Miller
Cover art copyright 1882 by John A. Marshall
All rights reserved. Published in the United States by Random House Studio, an imprint of Random House Childrens Books, a division of Penguin Random House LLC, New York.
Random House Studio with colophon is a registered trademark of Penguin Random House LLC.
Visit us on the Web! GetUnderlined.com
Educators and librarians, for a variety of teaching tools, visit us at RHTeachersLibrarians.com
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available upon request.
ISBN9780593181560 (trade)ISBN9780593181577 (lib. bdg.)ebook ISBN9780593181584
Random House Childrens Books supports the First Amendment and celebrates the right to read.
Penguin Random House LLC supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin Random House to publish books for every reader.
ep_prh_6.0_141688264_c0_r0
Contents
TO ANNIE
Let the rest of your friends say what they will, I still remain the same and always to the end.
MARY SURRATT
The living can write and talk, but the dead must depend on the supreme right of legal justice either to justify or condemn their fate.
JOHN T. FORD, PROPRIETOR OF FORDS THEATRE
WHOS WHO
THE SURRATTS
Mary Surratt: widowed mother of three; owner of a boardinghouse at 541 H Street in Washington, DC, and a tavern in Prince Georges County, Maryland
John Harrison Surratt Jr.: Marys younger son
Elizabeth Susanna Anna Surratt: Marys daughter
Olivia Jenkins: niece of Mary Surratt
John Zadock Jenkins: brother of Mary Surratt
MARY SURRATTS TENANTS
Apollonia Dean: ten-year-old student at St. Patricks Institute; shared Mary Surratts bedroom (not present on the night of the assassination)
Honora Fitzpatrick: seventeen-year-old boarder; shared Mary Surratts bedroom
John and Eliza Holohan: married couple renting two upstairs rooms from Mary Surratt
John Lloyd: leased Mary Surratts tavern in Prince Georges County, Maryland
Louis Weichmann: twenty-two-year-old War Department clerk and college schoolmate of John Surratt Jr.; shared John Jr.s bedroom at the Surratt boardinghouse
THE ACCUSED
Samuel Arnold: schoolmate of John Wilkes Booth
George A. Atzerodt: carriage painter
David Herold: former pharmacy student and druggists assistant
Dr. Samuel Mudd: tobacco farmer and physician
Michael OLaughlen: childhood friend of John Wilkes Booth
Lewis Thornton Powell (aka Reverend Paine and Mr. Wood): Confederate deserter
Edman Ned Spangler: sceneshifter at Fords Theatre
THE AUTHORITIES
War Department officials
Edwin M. Stanton: United States secretary of war
Lieutenant Colonel John A. Foster, Colonel Henry S. Olcott, and Colonel Henry H. Wells: officers chosen by Secretary Stanton to organize the influx of evidence in the investigation of the assassination
Arresting officers
John Clarvoe: Metropolitan Police detective; searched 541 H Street in the early-morning hours of April 15, 1865
George Cottingham: detective under the command of Provost Marshal OBeirne; arrested tavern keeper John Lloyd
Ely Devoe: assisted Major Smith in the arrest of the occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
John Lee: detective under Provost Marshal OBeirne; searched George Atzerodts hotel room
James McDevitt: Metropolitan Police detective; searched 541 H Street in the early morning hours of April 15, 1865
R. C. Morgan: assisted Major Smith in the arrest of the occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
James OBeirne: provost marshal of Washington, DC
Charles Rosch: assisted Major Smith in the arrest of the occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
Thomas Sampson: assisted Major Smith in the arrest of the occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
Henry W. Smith: detective under Colonel Wells; ordered to arrest occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
William Wermerskirch: assisted Major Smith in the arrest of the occupants of 541 H Street on April 17, 1865
Prison staff
General John Frederick Hartranft: special provost marshal of Washington, DC; in charge of the Old Arsenal Penitentiary
Major General Winfield Scott Hancock: commander of the military district of Washington, DC, and General Hartranfts direct superior
George Porter: army surgeon responsible for the health of the prisoners at the Old Arsenal Penitentiary
Captain Christian Rath: hangman appointed by General Hartranft
IN THE COURTROOM
Defense
Frederick Aiken: twenty-eight-year-old Baltimore attorney and former Union soldier
John W. Clampitt: twenty-six-year-old Washington, DC, attorney
Reverdy Johnson: Maryland senator and former US attorney general
Prosecution
John Bingham: Ohio congressman; appointed special judge advocate in the conspiracy trial
Colonel Henry L. Burnett: appointed assistant judge advocate in the conspiracy trial
Brigadier General Joseph Holt: judge advocate general of the United States Army; presided over the conspiracy trial
CHAPTER ONE
Washington City, April 15, 1865
It was two or three oclock in the morning when the bell of Mary Surratts boardinghouse at 541 H Street rang very violently. On the third floor, twenty-two-year-old Louis Weichmann, a former college chum of Marys younger son, roused himself from bed. After pulling on a pair of pants under his nightshirt, he ran barefooted down the stairs. Weichmann did not open the door immediately. Wary of middle-of-the-night visitors, he tapped on the inside of the front door to let whoever had clanged the bell know that they should stop.
Who is there? Weichmann asked.
Government officers, come to search the house for John Wilkes Booth and John Surratt, came the prompt reply.
Louis Weichmann had seen John Wilkes Boothone of the most famous actors in Americathat very afternoon. Booth had stopped by to speak with Mrs. Surratt just before Weichmann had driven her into the countryside on an errand. However, Weichmann and Booths mutual friend, Marys son John Surratt Jr., had left for Canada over a week before. Through the closed door, Weichmann informed the officers that neither of the men they sought was inside.