Barthel - Love or Honor: The True Story of an Undercover Cop Who Fell in Love with a Mafia Bosss Daughter

Love or Honor

The True Story of an Undercover Cop Who Fell in Love with a Mafia Bosss Daughter

Joan Barthel

In grateful memory

of two fathers:

Joseph

and

George

Liz raised her head from the pillow when the alarm buzzed. She groaned, and folded the pillow in half, covering her ear. Dont forget to comb your hair, she said in a muffled voice.

Chris was out of bed quickly; years of cops hours had trained him to come instantly awake. When he emerged from the shower, his hair was still wet, flinging drops of water across her pillow as he leaned down to kiss the top of her head. Comb your hair, Liz murmured. I will, Chris promised. See you tonight. Then he remembered that she had a weekend booking at a club in the Catskills. See you Monday, he said.

In the kitchen, he poured a glass of orange juice, but he didnt bother making coffee. Thered be plenty downtown. Brass or patrolmen, hairbags or rookies, cops survived on coffee.

He stood at the kitchen window, looking down at the quiet courtyard. Three young children, holding hands, were walking along the pathway to the street, with two mothers behind them carrying lunchboxes. An elderly man in white shorts and windbreaker was jogging on the opposite path, taking high, lengthy strides, as though in slow motion.

Watching this peaceful picture, Chris felt peaceful. As he set out from his apartment in Forest Hills to take the subway into Manhattan, he felt settled and comfortable. His second wedding anniversary was coming up; he was happy in his work with the street unit, doing buy and bust with drug pushers. After some rocky times in both his personal and his professional life, he felt hed straightened out. He felt good about himself.

Still, he couldnt help worrying, as the train rumbled through Queens, into the city, about why he had been summoned to a meeting at the Intelligence Division. He hadnt a clue. Hed been working the street when the message had come clattering over the teletype at the station: P O ANASTOS REPORT INTEL DIV 0900 HRS FRI .

All afternoon, cops passing in and out of the station had speculated and gossiped. The teletype directive couldnt mean a simple transfer; that order would have been spelled out on the wire, and wouldnt have involved the Intelligence Division. Anastos wasnt due for a promotion; in his seven years with the New York Police Department, hed gone quickly, within the first eighteen months, from uniform into plainclothes, and was successfully settled in the anticrime unit. It was too soon for another step up, even for a guy like Anastos. More likely, he was in trouble, some cops thought. Some of them hoped so.

Christian Anastos was thirty-three years old. He had a mop of black curly hair, bright dark eyes, a playful sense of humor and a flaring Mediterranean temperonce, when he was losing a burglar who was escaping over a fence, Chris had smashed the concrete wall below the fence so hard, in frustration and fury, that hed broken his hand.

That had happened in his early days at the 40th Precinctthe 4-ohwhen hed taken every chase, every case, very personally, when hed viewed it as his specific mission to save, maybe not the whole world, but this sordid wedge of it in the South Bronx. In that desolate neighborhood above Harlem, where the neighboring 41st Precinct was Fort Apache, the 4-oh was The Alamo. The label was not just a romantic flourish; the station house was often besieged, its doors barricaded against invaders, and buckets of water sometimes dumped from a second-floor window on the enemy below. Once, Chris was walking along the sidewalk when a garbage can filled with bricks was rolled off a rooftop, thundering to the pavement only about ten feet in front of him. When Chris and his partner Phil emerged from an apartment building where theyd spent about twenty minutes on a domestic dispute call, they found their radio car ablaze from a Molotov cocktail.

Even in quieter seasons, when the police themselves were not barraged, the South Bronx trembled. Every crime invented by man was practiced there, by experts and amateurs alike; only prostitution was uncommon, the neighborhood being too poor to support such a relatively expensive occupation. Armed robberies, rapes, and murders were abundant; more than once, during Chriss time there, the 4-oh recorded the first homicide of the new year. Cops came to expect that, a minute or two after midnight, somebody would be dead. On a day-to-day basis, people routinely wrapped thick chains around their television sets, then wound the end of the chain around the radiator. But there was not really a crisis of crime in the community. It was worse than that. Violence had passed beyond crisis, to become accepted as part of the tattered fabric of everyday life.

The 4-oh was not a plum assignment, so a guy who had screwed up somewhere elsetoo much drinking, too many times caught coopingsleeping on dutymaybe suspected of taking payoffswas likely to be dumped, moved from a quiet precinct to a high-crime post. It seemed a curious rationale, considering that such a desperate neighborhood called for the best men, not the misfits; considering that in the barrooms and back alleys, numbers runners and drug dealers were more than willing to cooperate with the police. In such a grievous climate, a man with a drinking problem was likely to find more sorrows he needed to drown. Sometimes, though, a man who was dumped into the 4-oh was indeed shocked into good behavior. One boss was famous for his ritual of bringing out a full bottle of bourbon every morning and setting it on his desk with an emphatic thump. The bottle was taped shut, with wide brown masking tape. For years the lieutenant kept the bottle on his desk to remind himself never to take another drink, and as far as anyone could tell, he never did.

Chris liked the 4-oh. Hed asked to be assigned to either the South Bronx or to Harlemdefinitely a quirk, some guys thoughtwhere hed have real work to do. He wasnt a bleeding heart; he was tough when he had to be, and stubborn when he didnt have to be. But he didnt become hardened, as some cops did, defensively. Where poverty bred despair, and despair nurtured criminals, he considered the plight of people in the neighborhood as a crime in itself. Theyre trapped. Theyre victims, he said. I really believe that! Maybe one out of a hundred can make it out of here, with some kind of talent, but the others are trapped here forever. If they have jobs at all, theyre low-paying jobs, in a factory or in a sweatshop or washing dishes. They have nothing to look forward to. You could stand on a street corner for a year and ask every person who passes, Did you see the play, A Chorus Line? and not one of them would say yes.

He was particularly aware of the problems of families, when he saw the long lines of women at bus stops, early in the morning, never any men. The women were more employable as chambermaids, in sweatshops, while the men stayed behind to linger on stoops, nowhere to go. It was destructive to the family, Chris knew, and he was careful never to degrade a Puerto Rican man; if he stopped a guy for speeding and saw a woman and some kids in the car, he called him Mister. In fact, Chris gave out fewer than ten traffic summonses in seven years, and one of those he paid himself. Hed written a ticket for double-parking, one Christmas Eve; when the man came out of a store, children in tow, his face crumpled in such dismay that Chris took it back. He didnt void it, which would have looked suspiciously like a payoff; he got a money order and mailed it in.