ECONOMICS IN RUSSIA
Modern Economic and Social History Series
General Editor: Derek H. Aldcroft
Titles in this series include:
The Popularization of Malthus in Early Nineteenth-Century England
Martineau, Cobbett and the Pauper Press
James P. Huzel
Taste, Trade and Technology
The Development of the International Meat Industry since 1840
Richard Perren
Alfred Herbert Ltd and the British Machine Tool Industry, 18871983
Roger Lloyd-Jones and M.J. Lewis
Rethinking Nineteenth-Century Liberalism
Richard Cobden Bicentenary Essays
Edited by Anthony Howe and Simon Morgan
Governance, Growth and Global Leadership
The Role of the State in Technological Progress, 17502000
Espen Moe
Triumph of the South
A Regional Economic History of Early Twentieth Century Britain
Peter Scott
Aspects of Independent Romanias Economic History with
Particular Reference to Transition for EU Accession
David Turnock
Estates, Enterprise and Investment at the Dawn of the Industrial Revolution
Estate Management and Accounting in the North-East of England, c.17001780
David Oldroyd
Across the Borders
Financing the Worlds Railways in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries
Edited by Ralf Roth and Gnter Dinhobl
Mining Tycoons in the Age of Empire, 18701945
Entrepreneurship, High Finance, Politics and Territorial Expansion
Edited by Raymond E. Dumett
Economics in Russia
Studies in Intellectual History
Edited by
VINCENT BARNETT
Bedfordshire University, UK
JOACHIM ZWEYNERT
Hamburg Institute of International Economics, Germany
First published 2008 by Ashgate Publishing
Published 2016 by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017, USA
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
Copyright Vincent Barnett and Joachim Zweynert 2008
Vincent Barnett and Joachim Zweynert have asserted their moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the editors of this work.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers.
Notice:
Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Economics in Russia : studies in intellectual history. (Modern economic and social history)
1. Economics Russia 2. Economics Soviet Union 3. Economics Russia (Federation)
I. Barnett, Vincent, 1967 II. Zweynert, Joachim 330.947
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Barnett, Vincent, 1967
Economics in Russia : studies in intellectual history / by Vincent Barnett and Joachim Zweynert.
p. cm. (Modern economic and social history)
ISBN 978-0-7546-6149-8 (alk. paper)
1. EconomicsRussia. 2. EconomicsSoviet Union. 3. EconomicsRussia (Federation)
I. Zweynert, Joachim. II. Title.
HB113.A2B345 2008
330.0947dc22
2007052264
ISBN 9780754661498 (hbk)
Contents
Vincent Barnett and Joachim Zweynert
Danila Raskov
Leonid Shirokorad
Alla Sheptun
Joachim Zweynert
Natalia Makasheva
William Coleman and Anna Taitslin
Vincent Barnett
Shuichi Kojima
Michael Kaser
Pekka Sutela
Andrey Zaostrovtsev
Vincent Barnett and Joachim Zweynert
List of Figure and Tables
Figure
Tables
Notes on Contributors
Vincent Barnett, Creative Arts, Technology and Science, University of Bedfordshire, England.
William Coleman, School of Economics, Australian National University, Australia.
Michael Kaser, St Antonys College, Oxford, England.
Shuichi Kojima, Department of Economics, Konan University, Japan.
Natalia Makasheva, Institute of Scientific Information on Social Sciences, Moscow Higher School of Economics, Russia.
Danila Raskov, St Petersburg State University, Russia.
Alla Sheptun, Moscow Finance Academy, Russia.
Leonid Shirokorad, St Petersburg State University, Russia.
Pekka Sutela, Helsinki School of Economics, University of Helsinki, Finland.
Anna Taitslin, Faculty of Law, University of Canberra, Australia.
Andrey Zaostrovstev, University of Finance and Economics, St Petersburg, Russia.
Joachim Zweynert, Hamburg Institute of International Economics, University of Hamburg, Germany.
Modern Economic and Social History Series General Editors Preface
Economic and social history has been a flourishing subject of scholarly study during recent decades. Not only has the volume of literature increased enormously but the range of interest in time, space and subject matter has broadened considerably so that today there are many sub-branches of the subject which have developed considerable status in their own right.
One of the aims of this series is to encourage the publication of scholarly monographs on any aspect of modern economic and social history. The geographical coverage is world-wide and contributions on the non-British themes will be especially welcome. While emphasis will be placed on works embodying original research, it is also intended that the series should provide the opportunity to publish studies of a more general thematic nature which offer a reappraisal or critical analysis of major issues of debate.
Derek H. Aldcroft
University of Leicester
Foreword
Many scholarly (and also some popular) books have appeared since the collapse of the USSR, dealing with various aspects of the transition from communistic or Soviet-style economic systems to capitalism or market-control forms of economy. Yet very few books have appeared in the same period dealing with the long but often overlooked tradition of Russian economics itself, and how this tradition has grown and developed over a significant period of time. In fact, in order to fully comprehend the current position of the Russian economy, some understanding of its alter ego in the intellectual realm (Russian economics) is certainly necessary. This volume, although in no sense a comprehensive guide to this neglected topic, aims to introduce the reader to some significant currents and features of Russian economic ideas broadly considered, and thus to complement the many available accounts of the very recent development of capitalism in Russia.