Maternalism Reconsidered
International Studies in Social History
General Editor: Marcel van der Linden
International Institute of Social History, Amsterdam
Volume 1
Trade Unions, Immigration and Immigrants in Europe 19601993
Edited by Rinus Penninx and Judith Roosblad
Volume 2
Class and Other Identities
Edited by Lex Heerma van Voss and Marcel van der Linden
Volume 3
Rebellious Families
Edited by Jan Kok
Volume 4
Experiencing Wages
Edited by Peter Scholliers and Leonard Schwarz
Volume 5
The Imaginary Revolution
Michael Seidman
Volume 6
Revolution and Counterrevolution
Kevin Murphy
Volume 7
Miners and the State in the Ottoman Empire
Donald Quataert
Volume 8
Anarchism, Revolution and Reaction
Angel Smith
Volume 9
Sugarlandia Revisited
Edited by Ulbe Bosma, Juan Giusti-Cordero and G. Roger Knight
Volume 10
Alternative Exchanges
Edited by Laurence Fontaine
Volume 11
The Working Class in Modern Spain
Edited by Jos Piqueras and Vicent Sanz-Rozaln
Volume 12
Learning on the Shop Floor
Edited by Bert De Munck, Steven L. Kaplan and Hugo Soly
Volume 13
Unruly Masses
Wolfgang Maderthaner and Lutz Musner
Volume 14
Central European Crossroads
Pieter C. van Duin
Volume 15
Supervision and Authority in Industry
Edited by Patricia Van den Eeckhout
Volume 16
Forging Political Identity
Keith Mann
Volume 17
Gendered Money
Pernilla Jonsson and Silke Neunsinger
Volume 18
Postcolonial Migrants and Identity Politics
Edited by Ulbe Bosma, Jan Lucassen, and Gert Oostindie
Volume 19
Charismatic Leadership and Social Movements
Edited by Jan Willem Stutje
Volume 20
Maternalism Reconsidered
Edited by Marian van der Klein, Rebecca Jo Plant, Nichole Sanders and Lori R. Weintrob
Volume 21
Routes into the Abyss
Edited by Helmut Konrad and Wolfgang Maderthaner
Volume 22
Alienating Labour
Eszter Bartha
Volume 23
Migration, Settlement and Belonging in Europe, 15001930s
Edited by Steven King and Anne Winter
Volume 24
Bondage
Alessandro Stanziani
MATERNALISM RECONSIDERED
Motherhood, Welfare and Social Policy
in the Twentieth Century
Edited by
Marian van der Klein
Rebecca Jo Plant
Nichole Sanders
and
Lori R. Weintrob
Published in 2012 by
Berghahn Books
www.berghahnbooks.com
2012, 2015 Marian van der Klein, Rebecca Jo Plant, Nichole Sanders and Lori R. Weintrob
First paperback edition published in 2015.
All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purposes of criticism and review, no part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission of the publisher.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Maternalism reconsidered : motherhood, welfare and social policy in the twentieth
century / [edited by] Marian van der Klein [et al.].
p. cm. (International studies in social history)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-0-85745-466-9 (hardback : alk. paper) ISBN 978-1-78238-680-3 (paperback : alk. paper) ISBN 978-0-85745-467-6 (ebook)
1. MotherhoodHistory20th century. 2. MothersHistory20th century. 3.
Social policyHistory20th century. 4. Public welfareHistory20th century. I.
Klein, Marian van der.
HQ759.M37365 2012
306.8743dc23
2011041080
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Printed on acid-free paper.
ISBN: 978-0-85745-466-9 hardback
ISBN: 978-1-78238-680-3 paperback
ISBN: 978-0-85745-467-6 ebook
CONTENTS
Rebecca Jo Plant and Marian van der Klein
Sonya Michel
Marian van der Klein
Lori R. Weintrob
Berteke Waaldijk
Lara Campbell
Rebecca Jo Plant
Nichole Sanders
Maria Lcia Mott
Elisabetta Vezzosi
Yoshie Mitsuyoshi
Alma Idiart
Rebecca Jo Plant
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
A New Generation of Scholars on Maternalism
Rebecca Jo Plant and Marian van der Klein
Today as much as ever, mothers and motherhood are categories to be reckoned with in political debates. In nations across the globe, policymakers and commentators discuss whether mothers should be compensated for the care work they perform; whether women should be offered incentives to prevent population decline, or, alternately, be pressured to slow population growth; whether governments should take special measures to protect women due to their reproductive capacity; and to what extent, if any, mothers tend to vote en bloc. Regardless of the type of governmental regime and the role envisioned for mothers, the language that politicians and bureaucrats employ when addressing questions related to mothers and children often seems remarkably similar and strikingly familiar. Though their appeals are frequently dismissed as empty political rhetoric, they echo longstanding gendered discourses that have deep roots in both cultural beliefs and material life.
Since the late nineteenth century, calls for child and maternal welfare programmes and mothers rights have emanated from all quarters of the globe, sometimes successfully, sometimes in vain. They have been advanced by liberals and conservatives, feminists and anti-feminists, men and women, a wide variety of religious groups and democratic, fascist and communist regimes. Moreover, as the celebration of Mothers Day in various countries reveals, discourses of motherhood not only encompass economic and political issues, but are also embedded in cultures of esteem and honour. In seeking to understand the myriad ways in which motherhood has figured within public life and social provisions, many scholars have embraced the paradigm of maternalism. It is this slippery construct that the essays in this volume attempt to analyse, test and refine.