To all my friends from the Dulles Colloquium, with fond memories of those many spirited discussions in the Union League Club, led by Father Neuhaus and Cardinal Dulles
JLW
Contents
Cover
Title Page
Copyright Page
Dedication
A
Abbreviations
Introduction
1. What We Have in Common
2. Tradition and the Traditions
3. Scripture: No Greater Authority?
4. Rome or Nothing?
5. Revelation, Biblical Authority, and Creed: How to Affirm Catholic Faith without Affirming the Claims of Rome
6. The Ch
7. The Church, Part II: Are Other Traditions Ecumenically Understood?
8. You Are Your Own Pope: The Tu Quoque Objection
9. Sacraments: Baptismal Unity and Separated Suppers
11. The P
12. Machiavellian Machinations and More: The Later History of the Papacy
13. Papal (Im)Probabilities
14. Protestants in the Crosshairs: Popular Roman Catholic Apologetics
15. Mary:
16. Mary Again: From Dogmatic Definition to Co-Redeemer?
17. Justification Roman Style
18. Justification: The Joint Declaration and Its Aftermath
19. Regeneration, Assurance, and Conversion: A Minor Chord in Roman Catholic Theology?
20. The Deeply Divided Church of Rome: The Worlds Largest Pluralist Christian Denomination?
Conclusion: A Come to Jesus Moment
Author Index
Scripture and Ancient Writings Index
Subject Index
Back Cover
Acknowledgments
I am grateful to the board of trustees and the administration of Asbury Theological Seminary for giving me the sabbatical that helped to make writing this book possible.
Thanks go to Dr. William Abraham of Southern Methodist University, who read much of the manuscript and offered many very helpful and insightful suggestions. I am also grateful to John Bugay, Reformed apologist, who read the work and offered well-received and much-appreciated counsel. Thanks also to Drs. Edwin Tait and Anthony Joseph, who read part of the manuscript and had several interesting observations and comments. A word of praise, of course, goes out to our friend and colleague, Dr. Ben Witherington III, New Testament scholar, who kept us grounded in Scripture. I am also appreciative of the faithful service of Rev. Andy Newman, who assisted in the research for this work, and of the advice of my fall 2016 Church History class who contributed to the process of naming the book.
Finally, I would like to express gratitude to my family: Marilyn; Brooke, Aaron, Kyla, and Darah; Lauren, Cody, and Gwenyth. They make all that I do a pleasure.
KJC
I want to thank several people who helped in various ways in the writing of this book, and made my chapters much better than they would otherwise be. First, I am grateful to several colleagues at Houston Baptist University who have discussed these issues with me over the past year or two and patiently endured my raising these topics at pub night more times than they would probably like to remember. They have also read some of the chapters and offered helpful criticism. In particular, I thank Dave Davis, Josh Farris, Bruce Gordon, Russ Hemati, Anthony Joseph, Tyler McNabb, Jeremy Neill, and Nancy Pearcey.
A number of other people have read chapters or parts of chapters and given helpful comments: Brandon Addison, John Behr, Petey Bellini, Al Howsapien, Peter Leithart, Paul Manata, David Opderbeck, and Glenn Peoples.
I am very grateful to Brian Hall, Timothy McGrew, and Josh Rasmussen, who gave expert advice for formulating my argument in chapter 13.
A special word of thanks to Billy Abraham, Brian Hall, Alan Rhoda, and Luke Van Horn, all of whom read several (in some cases all) of my chapters and provided insightful criticism.
Finally, I want to thank my family: Timothy and Angela Amos, Madelyn Rose, Mackenzie Grace and Abigail Joy; and Jonathan and Emily Walls. They always provide inspiration and encouragement, both directly and indirectly, for everything I write.
JLW
Abbreviations
Bibliographic
ANF | The Ante-Nicene Fathers : Translations of the Writings of the Fathers down to A.D. 325 . Edited by Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, and A. Cleveland Coxe. 10 vols. New York: Christian Literature, 18851887. Reprinted, Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1994. |
Catechism | Catechism of the Catholic Church . 2nd ed. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, 1994. |
JDDJ | Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999) |
LW | Martin Luther. Luthers Works. Philadelphia: Fortress; Saint Louis: Concordia, 195886, 2008. |
NABRE | New American Bible, revised (2010) edition |
NIV | New International Version (2011) |
NPNF | A Select Library of Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church . 1st series. Edited by Philip Schaff. 14 vols. New York: Christian Literature, 18861889. Reprinted, Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1994. |
NPNF | A Select Library of Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church . 2nd series. Edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace. 14 vols. New York: Christian Literature, 18901900. Reprinted, Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1994. |
NT | New Testament |
OT | Old Testament |
PG | Patrologia Graeca. Edited by J.-P. Migne. 162 vols. Paris, 185786. |
Miscellaneous
section |
AD | anno Domini, year of our Lord |
art. | article |
b. | born |
BC | before Christ |
c. | circa |
can. | canon |
cf. | confer , compare |
chap(s). | chapter(s) |
d. | died |
ed(s). | editor(s), edited by, edition |
e.g. | exempli gratia , for example |
EKD | Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland |
esp. | especially |
etc. | et cetera , and so forth |
i.e. | id est , that is |
n.d. | no date |
n(n). | note(s) |
n.p. | no place |
n.s. | new series |
par(s). | paragraph(s) |
r. | reigned |
RCC | Roman Catholic Church |
repr. | reprinted |
rev. | revised |
sec. | section |
s.v. | sub verbo , under the word |
trans. | translator, translated by |
v(v). | |