Gregory Chaitin [Chaitin - Meta Math!

Science is an open road: each question you answer raises ten new questions, and much more difficult ones! Yes, I'll tell you some things I discovered, but the journey is endless, and mostly I'll share with you, the reader, my doubts and preoccupations and what I think are promising and challenging new things to think about.

It would be easy to spend many lifetimes working on any of a number of the questions that I'll discuss. That is how the good questions are. You can't answer them in five minutes, and it would be no good if you could.

Science is an adventure. I don't believe in spending years studying the work of others, years learning a complicated field before I can contribute a tiny little bit. I prefer to stride off in totally new directions, where imagination is, at least initially, much more important than technique, because the techniques have yet to be developed. It takes all kinds of people to advance knowledge, the pioneers, and those who come afterwards and patiently work a farm. This book is for pioneers!

Most books emphasize what the author knows. I'll try to emphasize what I would like to know, what I'm hoping someone will discover, and just how much there is that is fundamental and that we don't know!

And yes, I'm a mathematician, but I'm really interested in everything: what is life, what's intelligence, what is consciousness, does the universe contain randomness, are space and time continuous or discrete. To me math is just the fundamental tool of philosophy, it's a way to work out ideas, to flesh them out, to build models, to understand! As Leibniz said, without math you cannot really understand philosophy, without philosophy you cannot really understand mathematics, and with neither of them, you can't really understand a thing! Or at least that's my credo, that's how I operate.

On the other hand, as someone said a long time ago, a mathematician who is not something of a poet will never be a good mathematician. And there is no permanent place in the world for ugly mathematics (G. H. Hardy). To survive, mathematical ideas must be beautiful, they must be seductive, and they must be illuminating, they must help us to understand, they must inspire us. So I hope this little book will also convey something of this more personal aspect of mathematical creation, of mathematics as a way of celebrating the universe, as a kind of love-making! I want you to fall in love with mathematical ideas, to begin to feel seduced by them, to see how easy it is to be entranced and to want to spend years in their company, years working on mathematical projects.

And it is a mistake to think that a mathematical idea can survive merely because it is useful, because it has practical applications. On the contrary, what is useful varies as a function of time, while a thing of beauty is a joy forever (Keats). Deep theory is what is really useful, not the ephemeral usefulness of practical applications!

Part of that beauty, an essential part, is the clarity and sharpness that the mathematical way of thinking about things promotes and achieves. Yes, there are also mystic and poetic ways of relating to the world, and to create a new math theory, or to discover new mathematics, you have to feel comfortable with vague, unformed, embryonic ideas, even as you try to sharpen them. But one of the things about math that seduced me as a child was the black/whiteness, the clarity and sharpness of the world of mathematical ideas, that is so different from the messy (but wonderful!) world of human emotions and interpersonal complications! No wonder that scientists express their understanding in mathematical terms, when they can!

As has been often said, to understand something is to make it mathematical, and I hope that this may eventually even happen to the fields of psychology and sociology, someday. That is my bias, that the math point of view can contribute to everything, that it can help to clarify anything. Mathematics is a way of characterizing or expressing