Journal of Museum Education
A Publication of the Museum Education Roundtable
Editors-in-Chief
TINA R. NOLAN, Ed.D
Interim Director of Partnerships, National College of Education at National-Louis University
CYNTHIA ROBINSON
Director of Museum Studies, Tufts University
Professionalizing Practice
A Critical Look at Recent Practice in Museum Education
Editorial Review Panel
AMELIA CHAPMAN, Curator of Education, Pacific Asia Museum
MARIA DEL CARMEN COSSOU, Program Coordinator and Acting Volunteer Manager, Office of Education and Outreach, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution
MARY KAY CUNNINGHAM, Museum Experience and Interpretation Specialist
KAREN L. DALY, Executive Director, Dumbarton House
BROOK DIGIOVANNI EVANS, Head of Gallery Learning Education, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
ERIK HOLLAND, Curator of Education, State Historical Society of North Dakota
MARK HOWELL, Program and Education Coordinator, Library of Virginia
CAROLE KRUCOFF, Head of Public Education, Oriental Institute Museum, University of Chicago
MARK LARSON, Associate Professor, Educational Leadership and Secondary Education, National Louis University
BETH MALONEY, Museum Education Consultant and Vice President, Museum Education Roundtable
ELISABETH NEVINS, Principal, Seed Education Consulting
ALEXA MILLER, Project Mentor, ArtScience Labs and Independent Arts Learning Specialist
SCOTT PATTISON, Research and Evaluation Associate, Oregon Museum of Science and Industry
VICTORIA RAMIREZ, PH.D., W.T. and Louise J. Moran Education Director, Museum of Fine Arts, Houston
NANCY RICHNER, Museum Education Director, Hofstra University Museum
LAURA ROBERTS, Advisor, Bank Street College Leadership in Museum Education Program and Independent Museum Professional
JULIA ROSE, Director, West Baton Rouge Museum
TANIA SAID SCHULER, Curator of Education, Ball State University Museum of Art
SUSAN SPERO, Professor, Museum Studies Program, John F. Kennedy University
LAUREEN TRAINER, Manager of Visitor Research & Program Evaluation, Denver Museum of Nature & Science
Photo Editor
ELISABETH NEVINS, Principal, Seed Education Consulting
Copy Editors
HANNAH HELLER, SARAH MARGERUM, TINA NOLAN, CYNTHIA ROBINSON
The Museum Education Roundtable (MER) is a nonprofit organization based in Washington DC, dedicated to enriching and promoting the field of museum education. Through publications, programs, and communication networks, MER fosters professionalism, encourages leadership, scholarship, and research in museum-based learning, and advocates for the inclusion and application of museum-based learning in the general education arena. For more information on MER and its activities, please visit the MER website at www.museumeducation.info and click on contact us. MER members receive the Journal of Museum Education as a benefit of membership. To join MER, visit the website at www.museumeducation.info or write to MER at PO Box 15727, Washington, DC 20003.
First published 2012 by Left Coast Press, Inc.
Published 2016 by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
711 Third Avenue,New York, NY 10017
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor and Francis Group, an informa business
Copyright 2012 Museum Education Roundtable
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers.
Notice:
Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Production and Composition by Detta Penna, Penna Design
ISBN 13: 978-1-61132-820-2 (pbk)
Contents
From the Editors-in-Chief
Compared to many other peer-reviewed journals, each JME issue comes to fruition in a relatively short time span. From the MER publication committee's approval of the guest-editors proposal to the journals arrival in your mailbox, the process takes just under a year.
This reasonable turn-around time (for a print publication) enables us to forecast and address current trends in the field in ways that are both timely and useful to our readers. In this issue, guest editors Scott Winterrowd and Briley Rasmussen respond to the continued confusion about what museum educators do by examining the history of museum education and assessing its evolution to spark conversations about its future, grounded in a shared understanding of where weve been. Another article expands upon the spring 2012 issues early childhood focus by turning a lens on babies mothers. Yet another asks the evergrowing number of museums that conduct simulated archeological digs with school groups to rethink the activity to better reflect actual process and scholarship. Still another article offers a critical response to an article published in the November/December 2011 issue of Museum News and challenges us all to think about the issue of authority and museum education in new ways. JMEs final volume of 2012 will continue the tradition of issue-based relevance. Guest editors Patrick Roberts and Asja Mandic are assembling articles that examine museum educations response to radical social change from international perspectives.
Looking toward the 2013 and 2014 JME issues, what topics and trends lie ahead and what should we be addressing? Issue-based questions that weve been discussing include:
How should museums prepare for an aging and diversifying population?
How can museum educators navigate the rocky shoals of outreach beyond museum walls?
How will museum educators continue to personalize visitors learning while avoiding the perception that they are then redundant?
What role, if any, do museum educators play in the reform of the public education system in the United States?
Journal of Museum Education, Volume 37, Number 2, Summer 2012, pp. 5-6.
2012 Museum Education Roundtable. All rights reserved. 5
We'd love to hear your ideas and see your proposals for guest-editing a section of an upcoming JME, or for contributing single manuscripts for consideration.
Contact us at: Cynthia.Robinson@tufts.edu and Tina.Nolan@nl.edu. You can also reach us both at our gmail site: jmuseed@gmail.com.
About the Authors
Cynthia Robinson, Co-Editor-in-Chief of the JME, is the director of museum studies at Tufts University. She spent 25 years working in and with museums and has extensive experience in developing programs, curricula, and exhibitions, as well as in museum management and administration.
Dr. Tina Nolan, Co-Editor-in-Chief of the JME, is Interim Director of Partnerships in the National College of Education at National Louis University. In addition, Dr. Nolan works with museums and other not-for-profit educational organizations as an independent education consultant, researcher, guest lecturer, and writer.