Luke Gormally - The Moral Philosophy of Elizabeth Anscombe

Title Page

The Moral Philosophy of Elizabeth Anscombe

Edited by

Luke Gormally, David Albert Jones and Roger Teichmann

Publisher Information

Published in 2016 by

Imprint Academic

PO Box 200, Exeter

EX5 5YX, UK

imprint-academic.com

Digital edition converted and distributed by

Andrews UK Limited

www.andrewsuk.com

Copyright 2016 Luke Gormally, David Albert Jones and Roger Teichmann

Individual contributions 2016 the respective authors

The moral rights of the authors have been asserted. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without permission, except for the quotation of brief passages in criticism and discussion.

Cover Photograph: St Salvators Quadrangle, St Andrews by Peter Adamson from the University of St Andrews collection

Other Books in this Series

ST ANDREWS STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY AND PUBLIC AFFAIRS

Founding and General Editor:

John Haldane, University of St Andrews

Values, Education and the Human World

edited by John Haldane

Philosophy and its Public Role

edited by William Aiken and John Haldane

Relativism and the Foundations of Liberalism

by Graham Long

Human Life, Action and Ethics: Essays by G.E.M. Anscombe

edited by Mary Geach and Luke Gormally

The Institution of Intellectual Values: Realism and Idealism in Higher Education

by Gordon Graham

Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Utility

by Anthony Kenny and Charles Kenny

Distributing Healthcare: Principles, Practices and Politics

edited by Niall Maclean

Liberalism, Education and Schooling: Essays by T.M. Mclaughlin

edited by David Carr, Mark Halstead and Richard Pring

The Landscape of Humanity: Art, Culture & Society

by Anthony OHear

Faith in a Hard Ground: Essays on Religion, Philosophy and Ethics by G.E.M. Anscombe

edited by Mary Geach and Luke Gormally

Subjectivity and Being Somebody

by Grant Gillett

Understanding Faith: Religious Belief and Its Place in Society

by Stephen R.L. Clark

Profit, Prudence and Virtue: Essays in Ethics, Business & Management

edited by Samuel Gregg and James Stoner

Practical Philosophy: Ethics, Society and Culture

by John Haldane

Sensibility and Sense: Aesthetic Transformation of the World

by Arnold Berleant

Understanding Teaching and Learning: Classic Texts on Education

edited by T. Brian Mooney and Mark Nowacki

Truth and Faith in Ethics

edited by Hayden Ramsay

From Plato to Wittgenstein: Essays by G.E.M. Anscombe

edited by Mary Geach and Luke Gormally

Natural Law, Economics, and the Common Good: Perspectives from Natural Law

edited by Samual Gregg and Harold James

The Philosophy of Punishment

by Anthony Ellis

Social Radicalism and Liberal Education

by Lindsay Paterson

Logic, Truth and Meaning: Writings by G.E.M. Anscombe

edited by Mary Geach and Luke Gormally

The Moral Philosophy of Elizabeth Anscombe

edited by Luke Gormally, David Albert Jones and Roger Teichmann

Preface

John Haldane

Elizabeth Anscombes article Modern Moral Philosophy, published in 1958, is in some respects a characteristic piece of work. It approaches its topic afresh, argues from first to last, introduces many striking ideas (some as asides), but is more concerned to identify fallacies and confusions and refute prevailing dogmas than it is to set out a theory of its own. It is unlike much of her work, however, in having a broadly narrative structure, and offering something of a historical survey. These two features may be attributable to the circumstances that led to its being composed: reading in short order a great many writings in moral philosophy for the purpose of tutoring in the subject, and undertaking to give a non-specialist talk on the theme of the title.

Like much of Anscombes work its freshness endures; but it also seems to have something of a prophetic character. The latter impression is due in large part to the fact that it gave rise to future developments in British, and later American, moral philosophy, so that looking back at it later it appeared to anticipate them. The main developments came in two phases: first, stalling and then reversing the trend to assume that there is no intrinsic connection between facts, values and practical directives; second, directing attention towards the category of virtues in attempting to say how one ought to act. Although the second is now the more prominent association, it is the first that she was herself more concerned with.

If Anscombe had written nothing else on ethics she would still have been known for Modern Moral Philosophy; and indeed many who know of it may have read little else by her on moral themes. Such is the unsystematic character of her writings that it is not obvious at first or second pass what the connections may be between her investigations of intention, promising, authority, killing and other topics. There is also the fact that much of what she wrote on first-order topics, or ethical questions, appeared in publications that would not easily come to the attention of academic philosophers; and remained uncollected in her lifetime.

Ten years ago St Andrews Studies in Philosophy and Public Affairs published Human Life, Action and Ethics: Essays by G.E.M. Anscombe edited by Mary Geach and Luke Gormally. A decade later three further volumes of Anscombes writings have appeared in the same series. I am very grateful to those editors for their work in making this body of material available. It includes a few essays previously included in earlier collected papers but which are now set in contexts of other hitherto inaccessible or unpublished associated writings thereby allowing readers to get a broader, deeper and more detailed sense of Anscombes thought.

Given this background it is very fitting that the volume immediately succeeding the last of Anscombes own writings should be a collection of essays exploring aspects of her moral philosophy. Here we see reflections on themes presented in the 1958 essay, but also on topics from earlier and mostly from later writings. As we proceed towards the centenary of her birth in 1919, thanks to Geach and Gormally and to the editors of the present volume and the authors they have collected, we are in a better position than ever before to understand Elizabeth Anscombes philosophy and to evaluate it.

As General Editor of the series I am grateful to all concerned, including Jared Brandt and Graham Horswell who were involved in aspects of the production.

Contributors

John Finnis is Biolchini Family Professor of Law, University of Notre Dame, and Emeritus Professor of Law and Legal Philosophy, Oxford University.

Kevin L. Flannery SJ is Professor of Ancient Philosophy, Gregorian University, Rome.

Mary Geach is the literary executor of Elizabeth Anscombe, co-editor of four volumes of her papers, and an independent scholar.

David Goodill OP is a lecturer in moral theology, Blackfriars, Oxford.

Luke Gormally is Director Emeritus of The Linacre Centre for Healthcare Ethics and co-editor of four volumes of Elizabeth Anscombes papers.

Edward Harcourt is a University Lecturer (CUF) and Official Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy, Keble College, Oxford.

David Albert Jones is the Director of the Anscombe Bioethics Centre, Research Fellow at Blackfriars Hall, Oxford, and Visiting Professor at St Marys University, Twickenham.

Anselm Winfried Mller is Chicago Moral Philosophy Seminar Visiting Professor, University of Chicago, and Emeritus Professor of Philosophy, University of Trier.

Matthew B. OBrien works in finance and formerly was a lecturer in philosophy at Rutgers University and a post-doctoral fellow at Villanova University.