Greenfeld Karl Taro - Boy alone : a brothers memoir

BOY ALONE

A Brothers Memoir

K A R L T A R O G R E E N F E L D

For Noah

CONTENTS

A CHILD

A BOY

A BROTHER

A C H I L D

A boy sits by himself on a stained white carpet, the corner of a frayed blanket stuffed into his mouth, his head bobbing, the fingers of both hands twiddling at ear level. He seems neither to miss company nor show any eagerness to seek it. If you say hello, he will not look at you nor turn in the direction of your voice. If you take up position in his line of sight, he will look away.

We lived in Croton-on-Hudson in a white house atop a black driveway along which wild blackberry bushes bore fruit in the summer. I used to walk up that driveway, stopping to pick the berries. No one else in my family knew they were there, and I never told anyone about them.

I dont recall the precise beginning of concern. I was born in Kobe, Japan, on November 26, 1964; Noah was born in North Tarrytown, New York, on July 1, 1966. As soon as I was aware of myself, there he was. How could I have seen that Noah wasnt like other boys?

What did I know of childhood development, normal or otherwise? I recall all the worry and conversation about Noah as steady background noise to which I would occasionally tune in. The two of them, my parentsmy father a head taller than my motherare sitting at the dinner table drinking tea after dinner, and their voices are low. Our

K A R L T A R O G R E E N F E L D

living, dining, and kitchen areas share one sprawling space at the top of a four-step rise from the entryway. I can sit on these steps, just out of sight, and listen.

They talk about Noah. Something is wrong with Noah. Noah should be doing this by now but he is not. Karlthey said my name!hes already doing this . And when Karl was two he was doing that . But Noahthey are already back to Noahhes not doing this .

This is serious, I know, a grownup conversation, with none of the careful enunciation or broad gestures that my father and mother use when they are talking to me. Their talk with me is meant, in part, to entertain me. This talk, this adult talk, is different.

I can also hear Noah. He is mumbling, repeatedly, a kind of dirgey stream of consonants, n-n-n-n-n-n, muh-muh-muh-muh, da-da-dada-da. He doesnt talk. Not in words, anyway. The boy down the street, Mark, is younger than Noah and he talks. I play with Mark. I cant really play with Noah, not anymore.

My parents are saying that Noah used to talk.

Im surprised. Noah talked?

What did he say?

Did he talk to me?

I stand up. My pockets are stuffed with Matchbox cars. I take Matchbox cars with me everywhere.

Noah is sitting in the den, on a tan sofa with a wood frame that faces the television. He is kneading his blanket like it is Play-Doh. He never watches television. I watch television every Saturday, the Lone Ranger the cartoon, not the live-action showand my mother makes me butter sandwiches on toast. I also have Lone Ranger pajamas.

Talk! I order Noah. Talk. You can talk.

He doesnt acknowledge me. He doesnt really look at me. He never really looks at me.

Mommy and Daddy said you could talk, I shout at him.

He never says a word.

BOY ALONE

On April 24, 1969, my father wrote in his diary, My sons: Karl is truth. He looks like a boy, reacts without deviousness, his life never far from the surface. Noah is beauty, sensitive rather than sensible, his life throbbing away in some subcellar. Karl laughs, audibly, openly.

Noah smiles, silently, mysteriously. Yet I cant deny it, Noah seems to regress more and more. He refuses to listen or to understand what we say to him, and has all but stopped talking. Its time to see the doctors again.

My father is a writer, and he rides the train to work in New York City. He wears a tan raincoat that smells like water. Our train station is at the bottom of the hill, beside the gray river. My father once took me on the train. We rode one stop, got off, and took a taxi back home.

Once, my father got a haircut while he was in the city, and when he came through the front door I didnt recognize him and I started to cry.

Noah didnt notice the difference.

My brother and I each have our own bedroom with a mattress on the floor. In mine, I have my toys piled in bookcases. Noah doesnt like most toys. But if a toy is made of plastic, he will chew on it.

He seems to like the texture, the malleability between his teeth. My mother believes chewing on these toys is dangerous, something about

K A R L T A R O G R E E N F E L D

the coloring being poisonous. Whenever Noah receives a plastic toy as a gift from our parents friends, it ends up in my room because I wont chew on it. Often, we each receive the same toys from fair-minded adults, and I end up with two of them. Two Spirograph sets, for example, when what I really wanted was a Billy Blastoff.

Noah is not interested in me. When I have nothing else to do, I will tickle him or wrestle with him. But that quickly becomes boring because Noah doesnt resist or tickle back. He just lies there giggling until I stop, and then he doesnt notice that Ive stopped or he doesnt care.

Im normal, my parents have said so in their hushed conversations.

And Noah isnt normal. And the rest of the kids on Hillside Avenue, they are normal, except for Dana, who shot someone in the eye with a slingshot. That cant be normal. But how can everyone be normal but Noah? How can Noah be the only one not normal?

I have other friends on the block. I have a swing in the front yard and a cat named Brodsky. The Robinsons next door have a swing set with a slide and a dog named Alexander. Tom lives next door on the other side, and he has a train set in the basement. Kirsten lives at the house at the bottom of our driveway, and her father built her an entire toy kitchen out of wood. I liked playing in the toy kitchen with her until Dana made fun of me. Kirstens older brother Arno has a ten-speed bicycle. He can ride all the way to the toy store by himself. I took three dollars from an envelope in the cabinet and gave it to him because he said he would buy me a Matchbox Mini Cooper. Instead he bought me a Volkswagen bus.

I go to the Scarborough School, and my best friend there is named Robe. He has a younger sister, Pierre. One day when his mother was picking him up from school and I was waiting for the school bus, she asked if Noah and I would like to come over some day and play with Robe and Pierre.

Why do you want Noah to come over? I asked.

BOY ALONE

Isnt he three?

I shrugged. What did that have to do with it?

I like fossils and dinosaurs, astronauts, the Lone Ranger, Matchbox cars, and now, lately, Hot Wheels. My father watches football and basketball, but I dont understand what they are doing. When I ask him how they play, he says, follow the ball.

I watch the ball, but I still cant figure out what is going on.

But at school, all the boys say they like football and baseball and basketball. Our favorite player is Joe Namath. Im not sure exactly who or what he is.

I dont consciously worry about Noah. He is a fact of my life, as much a part of it as our house or my parents or our blue Oldsmobile. Vaguely, there is a sense that something is wrong, that something in the center, at the heart, is not as it should be. But I cant put words or thought to it any more than I could elucidate my inchoate notions of God or the soul. But it is there, always, like an arrhythmic baseline underneath an otherwise happy family melody.