A Custodian of Grammar
Essays on Wittgensteins Philosophical Morphology
Kristijan Krka
university press of america, inc.
Lanham Boulder New York Toronto Plymouth, UK
Copyright 2012 by
University Press of America, Inc.
4501 Forbes Boulevard
Suite 200
Lanham, Maryland 20706
UPA Acquisitions Department (301) 459-3366
Estover Road
Plymouth PL6 7PY
United Kingdom
All rights reserved
Printed in the United States of America
British Library Cataloging in Publication Information Available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2011935317
ISBN: 978-0-7618-5652-8 (paperback : alk. paper)
eISBN: 978-0-7618-5653-5
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information SciencesPermanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1992
Acknowledgments
First, I wish to thank Josip Lukin with whom I wrote the second, fourth, and fifth essay. Josip also reviewed all other essays and made many objections, suggestions, and corrections.
Besides Josip I also wish to thank Luciano Bazzochi, Boran Beri, Stipe Buzar, Carol Caraway, Newton Garver, Russell Goodman, Peter Hacker, late Wasfi Hijab, Borna Jalenjak, Jeff Jordan, Jim Klagge, Timm Lampert, Jonathan Lowe, Winfried Lffler, Ivan Macan, Daniel Miin, Damir Mladi, Karel Mom, late Sinia Ourak, Michael Parnham, Davor Penjak, Alois Pichler, Alvin Plantinga, Duncan Richter, Nicholas Rescher, Joachim Schulte, Neven Sesardi, Nenad Smokrovi, Ivan Spaji, Thomas Wallgren, and Anja Weiberg for their helpful critical comments and suggestions regarding these papers during their development and during discussions after paper presentations.
Thirdly, apart from previously mentioned philosophers, I must refer to Wittgenstein scholars from all over the world that I met during the last decade in Kirchberg am Wechsel, Austria at the International Ludwig Wittgenstein Symposium (sometimes referred to as Kirchbergians ). Discussing many topics with them on numerous formal and informal occasions regarding Wittgensteins later philosophy was of substantive value for the quality of these texts.
Next I wish to thank my students and colleagues at my home institutions, Philosophical Faculty of the Society of Jesus in Zagreb and Zagreb School of Economics and Management , for their assistance in times when papers were completed and presented.
For proofreading the text I am very grateful to Luna Poli, Heather L. Smith, and Ivana Buljeta Banks.
Finally yet importantly, I wish to thank my wife Lana and daughter Emma for their astonishing patience and humour during last few years (I suppose one never heard so many jokes on the account of Wittgenstein, his life, and his philosophical ideas in such a short period of time).
Sources
The papers collected in this volume originally appeared in journals, symposia proceedings, or essays collections. However, if a paper was presented as a lecture on multiple occasions, only the most recent occasions on which a paper was delivered will be mentioned.
Chapter 1 (sections 2, 3, and 4) was delivered in Zadar, Croatia, at the DECOS International Conference (Describing Complex Systems), 2008, and was later published in K. Krka Illegal Substances and Unnatural Kinds, Trope Ontology as a Narrative Idealism (2009, www.filozofija.org, but only sections 24). Parts 1, 5, and 6 were delivered as a lecture at IUC in Dubrovnik, Croatia, during the international course Logical Foundations of Metaphysics at IUC, Dubrovnik, Croatia, 2009.
Chapter 2 was previously published, K. Krka, J. Lukin Wittgenstein the Morphologist I, Synthesis Philosophica, 46, (2/2008) pp. 427438. Section 2.5 is published in Disputatio Philosophica 1 (2009) pp. 323.
Chapter 3 was not previously published. However, the second part was delivered during the international course Logical Foundations of Metaphysics at IUC, Dubrovnik, Croatia, 2008, and the third part was delivered at Institut Detudes Politique de Lille, University of Lille 2, France, 2009/2010 as a part of the course Introduction to Ethics, Business Ethics and CSR .
Chapter 4 (sections 1 and 2) was delivered during the ALWS symposium (2007) and published: Krka K., Lukin J. Forms of life as forms of culture in: H. Hrachovec, A. Pichler, J. Wang (eds.) Philosophy and Information Society, Papers of 30. International Wittgenstein Symposium , Kirchberg am Wechsel, ALWS, Austria, 2007:11214. Sections 35 are published here for the first time and were delivered during a Postgraduate studies course in Analytic Philosophy at the Philosophical Faculty of the Society of Jesus in Zagreb, Croatia, 2007/2008.
Chapter 5 was delivered during the ALWS symposium in 2006 and published: Krka K., Lukin J. Wittgenstein on Consciousness in Philosophical Investigations , in: G. Gasser, C. Kanzian, E. Runggaldier, (eds.) Culture: Conflict-Analysis-Dialogue, Papers of 29. International Wittgenstein Symposium , Kirchberg am Wechsel, Austria, 2006:156159.
Chapter 6 was previously published: Krka K. Smells like Pragmatism, Wittgensteins Anti-sceptical Weapons, Prolegomena, 3, 2003:4161 and reprinted here with some minor corrections. Section 6.5 was previously published on the internet, Krka K. (2002) The Primacy of Practice , University of Passau, Equality Exchange, http://aran.univ-pau.fr./ee/page3.html.
Chapter 7 was not previously published. It was delivered during the course Special Topics in Epistemology during Doctoral Studies at the Philosophical Faculty of the Society of Jesus in Zagreb, Croatia, (summer semester of 2007/08).
Chapter 8 was previously published: Believing in God as Trust, as a Reasonable Thing to do, and as a Form of Life , in: Scopus, XI, no. 24, 2007:4363. As a lecture it was delivered on many occasions during 19992001, and in some parts it originated from some other papers and lectures.
In every case I am grateful to the editor for permission to reprint the pa-per here.
Abbreviations of Works by Wittgenstein and Used Symbols
Abbreviations of Works by Wittgenstein
AWL | Wittgensteins Lectures: Cambridge, 19321935 |
BB | Blue and Brown Books (BLB, BRB) |
BT | The Big Typescript |
CL | Cambridge Letters |
CV | Culture and Value (1998 edition) |
FL | Letters to Ludwig von Ficker |
GB | Remarks on Frazers Golden Bough |
LC | Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology, and Religious Belief |
LD | Wittgenstein in Cambridge, Lectures and Documents 19111951 (2008 edition) |
LE | A Lecture on Ethics |
LW | Last Writings on Philosophy of Psychology (I, II) |
NB | Notebooks 191416 |
OC | On Certainty |
PG | Philosophical Grammar |
PI | Philosophical Investigations (2001 and 2009 editions) |
PO | Philosophical Occasions |
PPO | Public and Private Occasions |
PR | Philosophical Remarks |
RFM | Remarks on Foundations of Mathematics |
ROC | Remarks on Colour |
RPP | Remarks on the Philosophy of Psychology (I, II) |
TLP | |
Next page