Joel Greenberg - A Feathered River Across the Sky

Of Prairie, Woods, and Waters: Two Centuries of Chicago Nature Writing

A Natural History of the Chicago Region

A Birders Guide to the Chicago Region (with Lynne Carpenter)

Copyright 2014 by Joel Greenberg

All rights reserved.
No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission from the publisher except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. For information address Bloomsbury USA, 1385 Broadway, New York, NY 10018.

Published by Bloomsbury USA, New York

Library of Congress cataloging-in-publication data

Greenberg, Joel (Joel R.)
A feathered river across the sky : the passenger pigeons flight to extinction /
Joel Greenberg.First U.S. edition.
pages cm
Includes bibliographical references and index.
eISBN: 978-1-62040-535-2
1. Passenger pigeon. 2. Extinct birds. I. Title.
II. Title: Passenger pigeons flight to extinction.
QL696.C6G74 2014
598.168dc23
2013016927

First U.S. edition 2014
Electronic edition published in February 2014

Visit www.bloomsbury.com to find out more about our authors and their books.
You will find extracts, author interviews, and author events and you can sign up for newsletters to be the first to hear about our latest releases and special offers.

To those who recorded what they saw; to those who collected the words; and to those whose love of beauty and life strive to make this story less likely to be repeated.

And to three others: Cindy Kerchmar, for enabling me to do this, and Renee and David Baade, whose support over the years has been extraordinary and deeply appreciated.

Now, Im sewing into the material
my red heart because the dead lately
have been a little noisy in my sleep

Tom Crawford, Prayer, The Names of Birds (2011)

My first recollection of reading about the extinct passenger pigeon was when I was in fourth grade at College Hill Elementary School in Skokie, Illinois. I checked out T. Gilbert Pearsons Birds of America and became so mesmerized I studied it relentlessly until the two-week period elapsed, after which I renewed it three consecutive times. Eventually, Mrs. Kelly, the librarian, encouraged me to sample other works that might interest me, including the Newbery Medal winner Gay-Neck: The Story of a Pigeon, about an individual Columba livia that flew messages on behalf of Allied troops in World War I. Although the story of the passenger pigeon crossed my consciousness while absorbing Edward Howe Forbushs account in Pearson, it became firmly lodged there in 1966 when I started birding as a twelve-year-old.

A year or two later my supportive parents responded to my request by giving me a hard-cover edition of A. W. Schorgers authoritative The Passenger Pigeon: Its Natural History and Extinction. Schorger was one of the countrys premier historians of natural history. He spent forty years collecting thousands of sources related to passenger pigeons, starting his research at a period early enough when it was still possible to interview people who had known the living bird.

The pigeons not only affected the ecosystems of which they were undoubtedly a keystone species, but also the consciousness of the people who saw them. Accounts survive attesting to the presence of the pigeon hordes over every major city of Canada and the United States, from the Atlantic coast to the Missouri River. They were part of the cultural and economic development of these two nations. As passenger pigeon historian John French wrote, they were martyrs to our progress. So this really is a story of people as much as birds.

Indeed, the interaction between these two species is yet another element that makes the story of the passenger pigeon unlike any other. As late as 1860, one flight near Toronto likely exceeded one billion birds and maybe three billion. Forty years later the species was almost extinct, and by late afternoon on September 1, 1914, it was completely extinct when Martha, the last of her species, died in the Cincinnati Zoo. Human beings destroyed passenger pigeons almost every time they encountered them, and they used every imaginable device in the process. Unrelenting carnage reduced the population to the point where it began its inexorable spiral to obliteration. Whether a concerted effort could have reversed the decline and altered the outcome was a question asked far too late for any attempt to have even been tried.

I think that if an attempt had been mounted early enough to gather a sufficiently large and diverse group of breeding stock, they could almost certainly have survived, even if gone from the wild, because the bird bred readily in captivity. If a wild reproducing population had somehow survived a few more decades, it could have been protected by the strict conservation measures enacted in the 1930sand based on scientific management, the species might still be with us, albeit in numbers much lower than billions. Modern Americans and Canadians coexist with cranes, waterfowl, and blackbirds that move across the landscape in flocks of many thousands or even millions, so why not passenger pigeons?

It is unusual when the exact date of an extinction is known with a strong degree of certainty. That the hundredth anniversary of Marthas death was fast approaching provided an impetus in my wanting to mark this event. It led to the writing of this book and a broader hope that this centenary could be a vehicle for informing the public about the bird and the importance that its story has to current conservation issues. In my research, I learned that others had the same idea, particularly ornithologist and pigeon scholar David Blockstein. We talked and began reaching out to other people and institutions. Among the first organizations I contacted were the Ohio Historical Society (which has on display the stuffed Buttons, one of the last known wild passenger pigeons), the Cincinnati Zoo (where Martha lived most of her life and died), and the Chicago Academy of Sciences Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum. This eventually led to a series of conference calls involving an ever-expanding group of participants, and then Notebaert graciously hosted a meeting in February 2011 that drew about twenty organizations from across the eastern half of the country. Several others participated via conference calling. Project Passenger Pigeon emerged from that gathering, and as of September 2012, over 150 institutions were involved. Our goal is to use the centenary as a teaching moment to inform people about the passenger pigeon story and then to use that story as a portal into consideration of current issues related to extinction, sustainability, and the relationship between people and nature. It is hoped that this tragic extinction continues to engage people and to act as a cautionary tale so that it is not repeated.

I have wandered through this land, just doing the best I can And I cant help but wonder where Im bound, where Im bound, And I cant help but wonder where Im bound.

TOM PAXTON, I CANT HELP BUT WONDER WHERE IM BOUND, 1964

Nothing in the human record suggests that there was ever another bird like the passenger pigeon. At the time that Europeans first arrived in North America, passenger pigeons likely numbered anywhere from three to five billion. It was the most abundant bird on the continent, if not the planet, and may well have comprised 25 to 40 percent of North Americas bird life. When the flocks moved for migration or foraging, the earth below would be darkened by shadows for hours: famed naturalist John James Audubon recorded a pigeon flight along the Ohio River that eclipsed the sun for three days.