All metrics are accompanied by targets. For the most part, these are percentages that will be ascertained via a calculation based on the entry of raw data. Some targets have the word baseline encoded. Baseline indicates that the metric is informationalfor example, only the raw value will be displayed (i.e., aggregated by the specified periodweekly, monthly, etc.). The targets should be set to default (or 0 in the case of baselined targets). The entirety of the metrics provided is greater than the norm for a typical balanced scorecard, which usually has just a few key metrics per perspective. It should be noted that many of these metrics can be modified to measure systems developed using social software engineering methods. In particular, note the social software engineering metrics listed at the end of the learning and growth perspective.
FINANCIAL |
OBJECTIVES | MEASURES | TARGETS | KPI |
Optimize cost efficiency of purchasing | Cost to spend ratio | <1% | F1 |
Negotiated cost savings | 20% | F2 |
Costs avoided/total costs | 10% | F3 |
Percentage of goods and services obtained through competitive procurement practices | 19% | F4 |
Control costs | Dollar amount under budget | Baseline | F5 |
Dollar amount over budget | Baseline | F6 |
Budget as a percentage of revenue | 30% | F7 |
Expenses per employee | 35,000 | F8 |
Cost of acquired technology/technology developed in house | 50% | F9 |
Percentage of new products/services where break-even point is within 1 year | 80% | F10 |
25% | F12 |
Cost performance index | 1 | F13 |
Average break-even point | 1.5 years | F14 |
Schedule performance index | 1 | F15 |
Total cost reductions due to use of technology | 33% | F16 |
Workforce reduction due to use of new products | 10% | F17 |
Contractor utilization | 35% | F18 |
Increase business value | Revenue from new products or services | Baseline | F19 |
Average ROI | 1 | F20 |
Percentage of resources devoted to strategic projects | 55% | F21 |
Percentage of favorable rating of project management by top management | 93% | F22 |
Average cost/benefit ratio | 22% | F23 |
Net present value | 1 | F24 |
Assets per employee | Baseline | F25 |
Revenues per employee | Baseline | F26 |
Profits per employee | Baseline | F27 |
Improve technology acquisition process | Total expenditures | Baseline | F28 |
Total expenditures/industry average expenditures | 1 | F29 |
Amount of new technology acquired through M&A | Baseline | F30 |
Operational costs/purchasing obligations (goods and services purchased).
Cost savings compared with total costs.
Costs avoided compared with total costs. You can avoid costs by reusing hardware/software, utilizing a partner, etc.
Difference between average qualified bid and the cost of the successful bid. The sum of each calculation is aggregated into a new savings ratio for all transactions.
e Additional capital costssoftware, IT support, software, and network infrastructure.
Technical support costshardware and software deployment, help desk staffing, system maintenance.
Administration costsfinancing, procurement, vendor management, user training, asset management.
End-user operations coststhe costs incurred from downtime and in some cases, end users supporting other end users as opposed to help desk technicians supporting them.
Overtime hours/regular hours worked.
Ratio of earned value to actual cost. EV, often called the budgeted cost of work performed, is an estimate of the value of work actually completed. It is based on the original planned costs of a project.
Break-even analysis. All projects have associated costs. All projects will also have associated benefits. At the outset of a project, costs will far exceed benefits. However, at some point the benefits will start outweighing the costs. This is called the break-even point. The analysis that is done to figure out when this break-even point will occur is called break-even analysis.
SPI is the ratio of earned value to planned value and is used to determine whether or not the project is on target. (See cost performance index for a definition of earned valueEV).
Cost of external contractors/cost of internal resources.
Use real dollars if systems are external customer facing. Use internal budget dollars if these are internal customer-facing systems.
Return on investment. Most organizations select projects that have a positive return on investment. The return on investment, or ROI as it is most commonly known, is the additional amount earned after costs are earned back.
The formula for ROI is
Organizations want the ROI to be positive.
NPV is a method of calculating the expected monetary gain or loss by discounting all expected future cash inflows and outflows to the present point in time. If financial value is a key criterion, organizations should only consider projects with a positive NPV. This is because a positive NPV means that the return from the project exceeds the cost of capital the return available by investing elsewhere. Higher NPVs are more desirable than lower NPVs. Formula for NPV:
- NPV = II+ (sum of) [OCF/(1 + R(r)t] + [TCF/(1 + R(r)n]
where:
- II = initial investment
- OFC = operating cash flows in year t
- t = year
- n = life span (in years) of the project
- R(r) = project required rate of return
from http://www.mtholyoke.edu/~aahirsch/howvalueproject.html
n Use research from a company such as http://www.infotech.com/